Peace be upon you, dear teacher. What is the appropriate limit for children regarding religious matters so that they do not fall into excess or negligence? Because sometimes we see that a child, during childhood, is encouraged by parents and those around them regarding religious matters, or is forced to accept certain things. When they grow a bit older and are influenced by friends and the environment, they gradually begin to feel negatively about being religious and distance themselves from it. Sometimes, the efforts of elders produce the opposite result. How can this balance be maintained within the family so that the child does not become confused? Unfortunately—and this is my personal opinion, but I have encountered this issue so often that I felt compelled to ask—religious people can be envious and have complexes, especially among women. A friend of mine who interacted with a group of veiled, religious women in Qom mentioned this and expressed her distress about it. Could you please explain the cause and root of these issues? Thank you.
How to Maintain Religious Balance in Raising Children?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
To maintain religious balance in raising children, one must avoid excess and negligence. Encouragement and affection should be proportionate to Islamic behavior, and enjoining good and forbidding wrong should be done with the child's innate nature in mind. Coercion is not permissible, but reducing privileges as a form of discipline can be beneficial. Religious advice should not be viewed as extreme.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterChildren are not exempt from advice, enjoining what is right, and forbidding what is wrong. Indeed, the responsibility of parents and every member of society in this regard is all the greater.
The path of the Straight Way allows neither excess nor deficiency. Any shortcoming or laxity along it, whatever name it is given—even “moderation”—is itself a deviation from the Straight Way.
No one, not even children, should be compelled or coerced to accept the truth. Although children should not be forced, reducing their privileges and special services as a form of discipline is not unreasonable. The special, compassionate affection shown to children should be commensurate with their Islamic conduct.
Enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong should not be neglected in the case of children, because it accords with their innate disposition; their hearts affirm it.
What is unwise is using methods contrary to the Sharia in raising people. We must not forget the guiding light of the Quran and the Prophet’s Household in educating and guiding people, our children, and others.
One of Satan’s ploys to obstruct the upbringing of children is to call religiously grounded advice “extremist.”