Greetings and respectful regards. Could you please explain: if the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) possessed divinely bestowed knowledge, why did he ask Gabriel about the phenomena he encountered there on the night of the Ascension?
If the Prophet (PBUH) Had Divinely Bestowed Knowledge, Why Did He Ask Gabriel Questions During the Ascension?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The Prophet’s (PBUH) questions to Gabriel on the night of the Ascension were not necessarily intended to acquire knowledge. They may instead have served to explain something, encourage someone, foster closeness, or draw on the other person’s capabilities. Moreover, the universe is continually expanding and developing under God’s will, and information may be shared with those who oversee that process.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterWe should bear in mind that the noble Gabriel عليه السلام is God Almighty’s envoy, with no role other than conveying His words. In reality, the Creator of existence, in accordance with His wisdom, speaks to His servant through Gabriel; it is the Creator who guides His Messenger.
From another perspective, we should note that a question is not always asked to obtain information; it may serve some other purpose. For example, a question may be asked to:
- elicit an admission;
- help others understand, persuade them, or encourage them;
- foster connection and intimacy;
- repeat and review what is already known;
- reprimand;
- make a point in the form of a question;
- sow doubt;
- evade an answer or divert the course of events;
- promote something;
- draw on the respondent’s abilities to advance particular aims;
- enlist the respondent or appoint them as a representative;
- honour, exalt, and revere the subject of the question;
- honour, exalt, and revere the respondent;
- demean, ridicule, or discredit;
- test;
and so on.
We should also bear in mind that a questioner may sometimes make use of the other person’s capacities to serve particular interests—for instance, by asking about their physical condition, clothing, and so forth.
We should further remember that divine works are continually being fashioned and carried forward. It is possible for a subordinate to be placed within one of these works and to pass information on to the engineers responsible for it.
By God’s will, and under His creative direction, the universe is expanding, developing, and growing. The realms visited by the Noble Messenger, the Prophet Muhammad صلی الله علیه و آله وسلم, were no exception.
الله اعلم بحقایق الامور و المسائل و الحکم