A friend of mine has a question. Could you ask the respected scholar about this? We are told that a believer should be humble, and patient and silent toward those who upset him, rather than reacting. First, doesn’t this undermine a believer’s dignity? Second, I have heard that to get things done, you should cover up other people’s mistakes and say nothing, because they will otherwise turn against you. Should one really accept such humiliation? And is it humiliation in the first place? Thank you.
Is a Believer’s Humility in the Face of Others’ Mistreatment a Sign of Passivity and Humiliation?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
True humility is before Almighty God. Toward His servants, it means showing practical respect and graciously overlooking their mistakes—not being passive or accepting humiliation. If outward displays of humility encourage others’ arrogance, one should preserve humility in one’s heart while exercising discretion in how it is expressed. One should conduct oneself with dignity toward disbelievers.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Centerلا حسب کالتواضع
True humility is humility before the Exalted Lord, and it can be attained only through knowledge of Him. The truly Great, the Mighty, the Majestic and the Supreme is God. To grasp this truth and act accordingly is the way of humility before the Exalted Lord. He is great in His very essence, while we are insignificant in ours; He is Mighty, while we are, in truth, lowly. Therefore, humble, submissive obedience before the Lord is a sign of humility and servitude. This is manifested through sincere obedience and worship!
Humility toward God’s servants means regarding all creatures as God’s servants and putting this truth into practice. Surely, anyone connected to the Divine Essence is worthy of respect, and this will break down any sense of superiority we might feel over them!
The reality of humility is not the same as its outward display. If displaying humility leads others to pride and arrogance, then in such circumstances one should preserve humility in the heart while exercising discretion in how it is outwardly expressed.
One should show the fullest humility toward the believers, but before the unbelievers, dignity should be the armor of every believer!
الفتح : 29 محمد رسول الله و الذین معه أشداء على الکفار رحماء بینهم ...
Muhammad (PBUH) is God’s Messenger, and those who are with him are firm and resolute toward the unbelievers, yet compassionate toward one another…
عن أبی الحسن الرضا ع قال قال: التواضع أن تعطی الناس- ما تحب أن تعطاه.
فی حدیث آخر قال قلت ما حد التواضع الذی إذا فعله العبد کان متواضعا فقال التواضع درجات منها أن یعرف المرء قدر نفسه فینزلها منزلتها بقلب سلیم لا یحب أن یأتی إلى أحد إلا مثل ما یؤتى إلیه إن رأى سیئه درأها «6» بالحسنه کاظم الغیظ عاف عن الناس و الله یحب المحسنین
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج2، ص: 124
Imam al-Ridha (AS) said: “Humility means treating people with respect and giving them what you would like them to give you.”
Another narration says: “I asked, ‘What is the measure of humility that makes a servant humble when he practices it?’ He replied: ‘Humility has degrees. One of them is that a person knows his own worth and, with a sound heart, places himself where he belongs. He wishes to treat no one except as he would wish to be treated. If he sees someone do wrong, he counters it with good; he restrains his anger, forgives people—and God loves those who do good.’”
اصول الکافی / ترجمه کمرهاى، ج4، ص: 374
The danger of humility
Showing humility toward God’s creatures because of their material wealth or outward advantages is a clear sign of associating partners with God!
و من أتى غنیا فتواضع له لغناه ذهب ثلثا دینه
نهج البلاغه (للصبحی صالح)، ص: 509
Whoever visits a wealthy person and humbles himself before him because of his wealth loses two-thirds of his religion!
In dealing with others, however, one should seek only God’s pleasure, whatever the circumstances!