Greetings. Is contemplating the Divine Essence forbidden to everyone?
Is Contemplating the Divine Essence Forbidden to Everyone?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Contemplating the Divine Essence is forbidden to everyone, because human reason and thought are among God’s creations and cannot comprehend His Essence. The furthest reach of thought is the Divine Names of Beauty. Imitation in matters of faith does not constitute genuine belief; one must attain certainty through innate reasoning. The silence on this matter should be broken by the Imam of the Age (AJ).
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterMy dear brother, matters of faith and the principles of religion are not to be accepted on the basis of imitation. Each person must come to believe in them with certainty through the evidence of their own innate reason. Otherwise, affirming the principles of faith and following the views of eminent scholars have no merit in the sacred domain of the revealed Law.
Any imitation in matters of faith is tantamount to having no faith at all. A servant of God must illuminate the heart with the light of faith; otherwise, before the radiant sun of others’ pure beliefs, each person will be like a blind eye, unable to benefit from the light.
Esteemed brother, please do not take scholarly matters out of their proper scholarly context. Knowledge is respected when it is pursued only by its own proper path.
The reach of thought is limited by the stature of the thinker. However much we may ponder, we cannot leap beyond our own measure. This is self-evident to everyone.
The farthest horizon of thought and reason ends at the Most Beautiful Names of God. How could God’s creation depart from the bounds of its created nature?!
The Divine Names are distinct from the Divine Essence. It can therefore be stated plainly that only the intellect has knowledge of the Names. Even thought is not of sufficient stature to comprehend the Most Beautiful Names of God, which are among His creations—much less the Divine Essence. There is no need to point out that intellect is distinct from thought!
Human thought, like the human being, is one of God’s creations. If thought were able to soar into the Divine Essence, that would imply that the Essence is limited, whereas سبحانه و تعالى عما یقولون علوا کبیرا
The Qur’an and the Prophet’s Household never intended to mislead us; they have made everything clear. If permission to reflect on the Divine Essence were possible, it would certainly have been mentioned. Even supposing, impossibly, that this matter had been left unspoken because of the limitations of certain minds, that silence would have to be broken by the Master of the Age and Time, peace be upon him!
(7) ضلت فیک الصفات، و تفسخت دونک النعوت، و حارت فی کبریائک لطائف الأوهام (8) کذلک أنت الله الأول فی أولیتک، و على ذلک أنت دائم لا تزول (9) و أنا العبد الضعیف عملا، الجسیم أملا، خرجت من یدی أسباب الوصلات إلا ما وصله رحمتک، و تقطعت عنی عصم الآمال إلا ما أنا معتصم به من عفوک
الصحیفه السجادیه، p. 148, excerpt from Supplication 32