One of Mulla Sadra’s glaring fallacies is that he infers a univocal meaning of the concept of existence from its multiple instances, then uses that univocity to establish the unity of the instances of that same concept, in order to prove the theory of the unity of existence!!!!! Isn’t this a vicious circle?
Is deriving the univocal meaning of existence from multiple instances a vicious circle?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Every creature, artifact, and existent has its createdness and existence in common, but this does not mean that God’s essence shares the attributes of created beings. The term “existence” falls short when used to describe God: He transcends all that pertains to existence and is beyond description.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterI have no intention of criticizing Mulla Sadra’s theories. I merely wish to point out that every creature shares in creation, every artifact in craftsmanship, every existent in existence, and so on. This does not mean—نعوذ بالله—that the Divine Essence shares the attributes of creatures. For it is argued that if we regard the existence of each creature as different from that of other existents, we end up denying their existence. But that is no different from regarding their creation as distinct. This has nothing to do with the Divine Essence, nor does it require describing God in terms of the attributes of creatures and other existents.
What special likeness do creatures share in their having been created and in their existence? Here, only the word has changed. We should not be afraid; rather, we should say aloud that God is the Creator of existence, and that He is higher and beyond existence and all that pertains to it, beyond description—even by the word “existence.” This very word, “existence,” is too feeble, powerless, and impoverished to raise itself in an attempt to describe the Lord.