Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2703 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Is Enjoining Good and Forbidding Wrong Obligatory for Everyone?

Primary reference: See the answer text 60 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2703

Please examine the following hadith in terms of its chain of transmission, explain whether and how it does or does not conflict with other verses and hadiths, and provide any necessary explanations.

May the Lord of all the worlds reward you.

Is enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong obligatory upon everyone?

و- بهذا الإسناد قال سمعت أبا عبد الله ع یقول و سئل عن الأمر بالمعروف و النهی عن المنکر أ واجب هو على الأمه جمیعا فقال لا فقیل له و لم قال إنما هو على القوی المطاع العالم بالمعروف من المنکر لا على الضعیف الذی لا یهتدی سبیلا إلى‏ أی من أی یقول من الحق إلى الباطل «1» و الدلیل على ذلک کتاب الله عز و جل قوله و لتکن منکم أمه یدعون إلى الخیر و یأمرون بالمعروف و ینهون عن المنکر «2» فهذا خاص غیر عام کما قال الله عز و جل- و من قوم موسى‏ أمه یهدون بالحق و به یعدلون «3» و لم یقل على أمه موسى و لا على کل قومه و هم یومئذ أمم مختلفه و الأمه واحده فصاعدا کما قال الله عز و جل إن إبراهیم کان أمه قانتا لله «4» یقول مطیعا لله عز و جل و لیس على من یعلم ذلک فی هذه الهدنه من حرج «5» إذا کان لا قوه له و لا عذر و لا طاعه قال مسعده و سمعت أبا عبد الله ع یقول و سئل عن الحدیث الذی جاء عن النبی
ص إن أفضل الجهاد کلمه عدل عند إمام جائر ما معناه قال هذا على أن یأمره بعد معرفته و هو مع ذلک یقبل منه و إلا فلا.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج‏5، ص: 60

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong is a strongly emphasized obligation that, depending on the circumstances, is regarded as either an individual duty (wājib ʿaynī) or a collective duty (wājib kifāʾī). Its necessary condition is knowledge and awareness of what is right and what is wrong. This obligation extends from the level of the prophets and the friends of God to the scholars, the righteous, and ordinary people, and each person, to the extent of their capacity and in accordance with their ability and knowledge, is charged with fulfilling it within a clearly defined framework.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

Enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong are among the most emphatic religious obligations. Depending on the circumstances, they may be either an individual or a collective duty.

Just as obligations such as prayer, fasting, and pilgrimage have essential elements, principles, and subsidiary rules that must be observed, enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong also has principles that those who undertake it must understand. Surely, someone with no knowledge of what is right and wrong cannot meaningfully enjoin the right or forbid the wrong. Knowledge of right and wrong must therefore precede the practice of this duty.

Someone who is ignorant of what is right and wrong is not exempt from the obligation to enjoin the right and forbid the wrong; rather, this makes their responsibility heavier. It is like someone unfamiliar with the rules and rulings of prayer: performing the prayer would have no meaning for them, and they must learn its rules as soon as possible so that they can pray properly. In the same way, everyone must become familiar with the duty of enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong, and with its rules, so that they can fulfil it.

Knowledge and understanding of what is right are therefore necessary conditions for enjoining it and forbidding what is wrong—just as anyone who intends to practise medicine must know both the illness and its cure.

Thus, this duty does not cease to be incumbent upon those who are uninformed. Rather, their responsibility is all the greater, since they are culpable for their ignorance of what is right and wrong.

Enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong extends from the level of the prophets and the awliya to that of scholars, the righteous, and ordinary people.

Everyone is charged with fulfilling this duty at their own level, according to their abilities and knowledge, and within its prescribed limits.

Hadith: Imam al-Baqir علیه السلام said: “In the end times, there will be people who follow a certain group of hypocrites, who pretend to be reciters of the Qur’an and devout worshippers. They are inexperienced and naïve. They do not consider enjoining what is right or forbidding what is wrong obligatory unless they are safe from harm; they are always finding excuses and pretexts for themselves. They seize upon the mistakes and lapses in the conduct and words of true scholars. In public, they turn to prayer and fasting and to deeds that pose no danger to their lives or their wealth. If circumstances should arise in which even performing the prayer put their wealth or bodies at risk, they would abandon prayer too, just as they have abandoned the loftiest and most excellent of duties.

“Enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong is a great duty on which the observance of all other duties depends. When people become like this and follow such individuals, God’s wrath against them will be complete, and God will punish everyone. Thus the righteous will perish alongside the wicked, and children alongside adults.

“Enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong is the way of the prophets and the path of the righteous. It is a great duty on which the observance of all other duties depends. Through it, roads are made safe, earnings become lawful, wrongs are redressed, and the earth is built up. Through enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong, even enemies are made to act fairly, and affairs are set right.

“Reject wrongdoing in your hearts, speak to them with your tongues, and strike them on their foreheads. Do not fear the reproach of any reproacher for God’s sake. If they take heed and return to the truth, then there is no cause to censure them. Censure is due only to those who wrong people and transgress on earth without right. These are the ones for whom there is a painful punishment. Then fight them with your bodies, and hate them in your hearts—but do not seek power or wealth, or seek to prevail over others through oppression. Do this so that they may return to God’s command and follow His obedience.”

He went on to say: “God revealed to the prophet Shuʿayb (علیه السلام): ‘I will punish one hundred thousand of your people: forty thousand evildoers and sixty thousand among the best of them.’ Shuʿayb (علیه السلام) said, ‘My Lord, the evildoers deserve this; but why are the righteous being punished?’ God revealed to him: ‘They were indulgent toward those who sinned, and did not grow angry for My sake.’”

عن جابر عن أبی جعفر ع قال: یکون فی آخر الزمان قوم یتبع فیهم قوم مراءون یتقرءون و یتنسکون حدثاء سفهاء «2» لا یوجبون أمرا بمعروف و لا نهیا عن منکر إلا إذا أمنوا الضرر «3» یطلبون لأنفسهم الرخص و المعاذیر یتبعون زلات العلماء و فساد عملهم یقبلون على الصلاه و الصیام و ما لا یکلمهم‏ «4» فی نفس و لا مال و لو أضرت الصلاه بسائر ما یعملون بأموالهم و أبدانهم لرفضوها کما رفضوا أسمى الفرائض و أشرفها إن الأمر بالمعروف و النهی
عن المنکر فریضه عظیمه بها تقام‏ الفرائض هنالک یتم غضب الله عز و جل علیهم فیعمهم بعقابه فیهلک الأبرار فی دار الفجار و الصغار فی دار الکبار إن الأمر بالمعروف و النهی عن المنکر سبیل الأنبیاء و منهاج الصلحاء فریضه عظیمه بها تقام الفرائض و تأمن المذاهب‏ «1» و تحل المکاسب و ترد المظالم و تعمر الأرض و ینتصف من الأعداء و یستقیم الأمر «2» فأنکروا بقلوبکم و الفظوا بألسنتکم و صکوا بها جباههم‏ «3» و لا تخافوا فی الله لومه لائم فإن اتعظوا و إلى الحق رجعوا فلا سبیل علیهم- إنما السبیل على الذین یظلمون الناس و یبغون‏ فی الأرض بغیر الحق أولئک لهم عذاب ألیم‏ «4» هنالک‏ «5» فجاهدوهم بأبدانکم و أبغضوهم بقلوبکم غیر طالبین سلطانا و لا باغین مالا و لا مریدین بظلم ظفرا «6» حتى یفیئوا إلى أمر الله و یمضوا على طاعته قال و أوحى الله عز و جل إلى شعیب النبی ص أنی معذب من قومک مائه ألف أربعین ألفا من شرارهم و ستین ألفا من خیارهم فقال ع یا رب هؤلاء الأشرار فما بال الأخیار فأوحى الله عز و جل إلیه داهنوا أهل المعاصی‏ «7» و لم یغضبوا لغضبی.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه) ؛ ج‏5 ؛ ص55

عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: قال النبی ص کیف بکم إذا فسدت نساؤکم و فسق شبابکم و لم تأمروا بالمعروف و لم تنهوا عن المنکر فقیل له و یکون ذلک یا رسول الله فقال نعم و شر من ذلک کیف بکم إذا أمرتم بالمنکر و نهیتم عن المعروف فقیل له یا رسول الله و یکون ذلک قال نعم و شر من ذلک کیف بکم إذا رأیتم المعروف منکرا و المنکر معروفا.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه) ؛ ج‏5 ؛ ص59

“What will you do when your women become corrupt, your young men turn to wickedness, and you neither enjoin what is right nor forbid what is wrong?” He was asked, “O Messenger of God, will this really happen?” He replied, “Yes, and worse than that. What will you do when you enjoin what is wrong and forbid what is right?” He was asked, “O Messenger of God, will that really happen?” He replied, “Yes, and worse than that: when you regard what is right as wrong and what is wrong as right.”

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022