If the Infallible Ones (PBUH) had not existed, would God not have created us ordinary human beings? That is, if in God's knowledge none of God's servants were to attain the station of divine vicegerency, would God not have created the world and all that is in it at all?
Would Creation Have Been Possible Without the Infallible Ones (PBUH)?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
According to well-known hadiths, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) is presented as the cause of the creation of the heavens and all beings. He is like a tree that has brought forth the fruits of creation. The universe is a manifestation of divine knowledge, and the Muhammadan light (PBUH) is the source of the principles of all that is good and beautiful and of the station of divine vicegerency; however, the realm of creation in its other dimensions is not limited to the divine vicegerent.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterAccording to well-known hadiths, the heavens and all creatures were created for the sake of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). He is likened to a tree through which the One Creator brought forth the sweet fruits of creation. Though He was capable of creating fruit without a tree, in His peerless wisdom He chose to bring it about in this way.
If we regard the heavens and all creatures as one spectrum of creation, then the Creator has displayed only a glimmer of His splendor and majesty. He may well have brought into being unknown spectra of existence, concealed from other creatures. In light of the well-known hadiths indicating that the world was created through the Muhammadan Light, we may understand that the Creator has displayed one kind of existence through the light and beauty of Muhammad and his family (peace be upon them), while our understanding and perception extend only to a part of the order of creation.
The universe is a manifestation of divine knowledge, and the Muhammadan Light issues from a glimmer of that knowledge. It is the principle of حسن المحاسن, and among its defining qualities is the station of divine vicegerency. Yet creation, in its other dimensions, both hidden and manifest, is not confined to the divine vicegerent; it also appears through signs, likenesses, words, and the like.