Peace be upon you. In traditional medicine, people are said to have different characteristics depending on their temperament and circumstances. For example, those with a bilious temperament are quick to anger, and this is considered one of their physical traits. Yet anger is a moral failing. What, then, is expected of such people? Is every instance of anger counted as a sin, even when it is not their fault and is part of their physical constitution?
Is Every Anger a Sin, Even When It Stems from One’s Temperament?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Although the human heart and soul are affected by the body, they are neither enslaved nor ruled by it; rather, the human soul influences the body. A person’s anger has nothing to do with a bilious temperament, and an excess of bile cannot disrupt the balance of a believer’s temperament. The lofty spirit of a true believer is so firmly attached to the highest realm that the lowly body cannot influence it.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterAlthough the human heart and soul are affected by the body, they are not its captives or subject to its rule. Rather, it is the human soul that influences the body.
A person’s anger has nothing to do with a bilious temperament. Someone may be in perfect physical balance, yet their spiritual temperament may change. Pride, envy, greed, covetousness, and the like arise from the smoke of anger!
Even if a person’s bodily temperament changes—for example, if they become bilious—an excess of bile cannot disrupt the balanced temperament of a person of faith.
Hunger and thirst, fullness, and changes in the seasons and circumstances can alter a person’s temperament, but none of them can affect the heart and soul of a believer!
The lofty spirit of a true believer is so firmly attached to the highest realm that their lowly body can influence it. And let us remember that the body is only a very small part of the vast human system.
All the questions were raised in the Telegram group “Cave of Questions and Ruby of Answers,” and the answers are from Master Ali Saei.