Question 74
Is the concept of existence graded? (Although it is not a univocal concept, is it graded? Like goodness, which descends from God and becomes ever more attenuated, until, if someone fails to receive it, we attribute evil to them. That is why we say evil is relative.)
**Master Ali Saei’s answer**
🍀🌱🍀 To regard existence as graded and extend it to both Creator and creature creates problems for the principles and beliefs of pure monotheism!
When we posit different degrees of existence, assigning the highest degree to God and a lower degree to creatures, we inevitably fall into a serious error of reasoning!
Why?
When we conceive of God as possessing existence in its highest degree, and then posit a lower degree of it, we thereby limit the Unlimited!
For that very highest degree has a lower degree on the other side, and every lower degree has an endpoint!
In effect, we have made the grave mistake of treating God’s existence as unlimited in one respect, yet limited in another!
What, then, is the remedy? What should we do?
The grave error lies here: with all due respect, we have sat down to ponder and reason about God’s essence, and—God forbid—we seek, with our limited understanding and reason, to comprehend God’s existence and measure its relation to creatures! Without even realizing it, we thereby enter the realm of associating partners with God!
Speaking about God’s essence is forbidden!
Speaking about God’s existence is tantamount to speaking about God’s essence!
So speaking about God’s existence is forbidden!
If God has existence, it is certainly «لیس کمثله وجود«.