Peace be upon you, dear teacher. This is a question from a friend.
Greetings. @ Knowledge is one of God’s attributes. The Shi‘i Imams say: العلم ذاته — knowledge is His very Essence. And anyone who considers the reality of knowledge to be created has, according to the Imams’ teachings, departed from wilayah. Furthermore, even if we were to assume that a na‘t is distinct from an attribute, when identifying examples of na‘t we would have to include life, knowledge, and power. The Imam says (والنعوت ذاته), which would mean العلم ذاته; therefore, it is not created.
Is God’s knowledge created, or is it identical with His Essence?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
God’s knowledge is uncreated; it is identical with His very Essence. Discernment of hadith takes precedence over its transmission, and reports must be weighed against the Qur’an and sound hadith. The intended meaning of «العلم ذاته» is that ignorance is negated of the Divine Essence and that God’s knowledge encompasses all creatures without any intermediary. God is exalted above being described by knowledge; rather, He is the One who brings knowledge into manifestation.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterWhen we receive a report attributed to the Infallibles, we must bear several important principles in mind when assessing whether its attribution is sound:
Can the report be corroborated by the Qur’an?
Can it be corroborated by sound reports?
If it is an ambiguous report, can it be corroborated by clear and decisive reports?
Did the narrator transmit the Infallible’s full statement, or was it reported in excerpts?
Did the narrator convey the meaning, or transmit the words verbatim?
And so on.
Understanding a hadith, then, takes precedence over merely transmitting it. Discovering what the Infallible intended by his noble words is one of the essential considerations in explaining a hadith.
The person addressed by the Infallible, and that person’s capacity for understanding and comprehension, will determine the scope of the hadith. Did the Imam make this statement in response to someone? What was that person’s level of knowledge and understanding?
If the Infallible addressed the general public, the Imam would surely have had their average level of understanding in mind.
Did he present the matter to someone especially perceptive? In that case, the Infallible’s words would have a particular depth.
Did the Infallible, peace be upon him, express the matter in symbolic terms, or did the narrator derive the report from the personal supplications of the Infallibles? Each of these, without doubt, has its own distinct scope and level.
و من کلام أمیر المؤمنین ع علیکم بالدرایات لا بالروایات همه السفهاء الروایه و همه العلماء الدرایه تزاوروا و تذاکروا الحدیث إلا تفعلوا یدرس
کنز الفوائد، ج2، ص: 32
“You should pursue a deep understanding of hadith, not merely its transmission. The concern of the foolish is to collect reports; the concern of the learned is to understand them. Visit one another and recall hadith together; otherwise, it will grow old and be lost.”
In light of the many contextual indications, the intended meaning of «العلم ذاته » in the Imam’s statement is that every kind of ignorance and lack of awareness is negated of the Essence of the Real, and that His knowledge encompasses all creatures without any intermediary.
Just as God is «عظیم العظمه», so too, in relation to knowledge, He is «علیم العلم» and cannot be described by knowledge. Rather, الله اکبر: the Creator is too great to be described by knowledge. He is above and beyond knowledge; He is the one who brings knowledge into manifestation and makes it apparent.
Let us consider this statement of the Imam alongside the other statements of the Infallibles, whose rightful authority is fully and conclusively established:
و کمال الإخلاص له نفی الصفات عنه لشهاده کل صفه أنها غیر الموصوف و شهاده کل موصوف أنه غیر الصفه فمن وصف الله سبحانه فقد قرنه و من قرنه فقد ثناه و من ثناه فقد جزأه و من جزأه فقد جهله
نهج البلاغه
“The perfection of devotion to Him lies in denying attributes of Him, for every attribute bears witness that it is other than that which it describes, and everything described bears witness that it is other than the attribute. Whoever attributes qualities to God, Glorified be He, has joined Him to something; whoever joins Him to something has made Him two; whoever makes Him two has divided Him; and whoever divides Him has failed to know Him.”
الممتنعه من الصفات ذاته و من الأبصار رؤیته و من الأوهام الإحاطه به ... فمن وصف الله فقد حده و من حده فقد عده و من عده فقد أبطل أزله ...
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج1، ص: 139
“His Essence is beyond attributes; His vision is beyond the reach of eyes, and His encompassing is beyond the reach of imagination … Whoever describes God has set limits for Him; whoever sets limits for Him has counted Him; and whoever counts Him has negated His eternity …”