Is it correct to divide the faculties of the human soul into the following: rational, estimative, irascible, and appetitive? Could you please give a more precise classification? May God grant you and us success in attaining His pleasure.
Is it correct to divide the faculties of the soul into the rational, estimative, irascible, and appetitive faculties?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The account of the soul’s faculties in *Tawḥīd al-Mufaḍḍal* includes biological drives such as hunger and sexual desire, as well as bodily faculties such as attraction, retention, digestion, and expulsion. It also refers to intellectual faculties such as thought, estimation, reason, and memory, and explains the importance of each in human life.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center(Part One)
Apart from the intellect and its seventy-five forces!
Among the stimuli and active faculties within the human being, as discussed in the school of al-Sadiq, descendant of Muhammad صلی الله علیه و آله و سلم, are hunger, sleep, sexual desire, and the faculties of attraction, digestion, expulsion, and retention.
Reflect, O Mufaddal, on the acts that God Most High has ordained for human beings: eating, sleeping, and sexual intercourse—and on the wise ordering He has established in each of them. For each of these acts He has placed within the human soul a stimulus that inclines a person to perform it and urges them toward it. Hunger impels a person to eat, on which the body’s life and well-being depend. Fatigue and sleeplessness impel a person to sleep, through which the body finds rest and its faculties are renewed. Sexual desire impels a person to intercourse, through which the human race continues and its kind endures.
If there were no hunger, and people ate only because they knew their bodies needed food—with no natural impulse compelling them to eat—they would often grow weary of eating and neglect it until their bodies wasted away and they perished. It is much like the way a person may need medicine to restore their health, yet put it off until a deadly illness takes hold and brings death.
Likewise, if people slept only because they knew that their bodies and faculties needed rest, they might, through inertia or a desire to keep working, put off sleep until their bodies grew weak.
And if sexual intercourse served only to conceive a child, people might well grow lax and abstain from it, until the population dwindled or died out. For some people have no desire for children and take no interest in them.
Consider, then, how the All-Wise, All-Knowing Lord has appointed a natural impulse within the soul for each of these acts on which the body’s well-being and stability depend—an impulse that urges people to them and compels them to act.
Know that the human being has four faculties:
First, the faculty of attraction, which draws in food and conveys it to the stomach.
Second, the faculty of retention, which keeps food in the stomach and elsewhere until nature has completed its work upon it.
Third, the faculty of digestion, which cooks the food in the stomach, separates out what is nourishing, and distributes it throughout the body.
Fourth, the faculty of expulsion, which gradually removes the waste left over after digestion has extracted what is nourishing in the amount the body needs.
Reflect, then, on the design of these four faculties in the body and on their functions, for the body needs them all—and on the wisdom and careful ordering evident in them.
If there were no faculty of attraction, how would a person be moved to seek food, on which the body depends for its well-being?
If there were no faculty of retention, how would food remain inside the body for the stomach to digest it?
If there were no faculty of digestion, how would food be transformed, so that what is nourishing could be separated from it, become sustenance for the body, and replace what the body has used up?
And if there were no faculty of expulsion, how would the waste left after digestion be gradually eliminated?
Do you not see how the All-Wise, All-Powerful Creator has entrusted these faculties to your body through His subtle craftsmanship and perfect design, and how they carry out what is best for the body? Let me offer you an illustration.
The body is like a king’s palace. In that palace are courtiers, servants, attendants, and stewards, each charged with managing what is needed for their welfare: one to bring the courtiers and their retinue what they need; another to receive what comes in and keep it until it is needed; another to process it, prepare it, and distribute each person’s share; and another to keep the palace clean of refuse.
Know, then, that the “king” is the Wise Creator, sovereign of all the worlds; the “palace” is this body; the “courtiers” are its limbs and organs; and the “stewards” are the four faculties just described.
The account of these faculties and their functions that we have given, and clarified in such detail, differs from the way physicians describe them in their books. They explain them in terms useful for the practice of medicine and the diagnosis of diseases. We have described them in a way that dispels doubt and uncertainty from people’s souls, and removes from their sight the veils, blindness, and clouded vision that keep them from recognizing the truth, so that they may acknowledge, with certainty and conviction, the existence and wisdom of the Lord of the worlds.
Tawhid al-Mufaddal / translated by Allamah Majlisi, p. 88
Know that the human being has four faculties:
Tawhid al-Mufaddal / translated by Allamah Majlisi, p. 89
#Response564 (Part Two)
Arabic text
فکر یا مفضل فی الأفعال التی جعلت فی الإنسان من الطعم و النوم و الجماع و ما دبر فیها فإنه جعل لکل واحد منها فی الطباع نفسه محرک یقتضیه و یستحث به فالجوع یقتضی الطعم الذی فیه راحه البدن و قوامه و الکرى «2» یقتضی النوم الذی فیه راحه البدن و إجمام «3» قواه و الشبق یقتضی الجماع الذی فیه دوام النسل و بقاؤه و لو کان الإنسان إنما یصیر إلى أکل الطعام لمعرفته بحاجه بدنه إلیه و لم یجد من طباعه شیئا یضطره إلى ذلک کان خلیقا أن یتوانى «5» عنه أحیانا بالثقل و الکسل حتى ینحل بدنه فیهلک کما یحتاج الواحد إلى الدواء لشیء مما یصلح به بدنه فیدافع به حتى یؤدیه ذلک إلى المرض و الموت و کذلک لو کان إنما یصیر إلى النوم بالفکر فی حاجته إلى راحه البدن و إجمام قواه کان عسى أن یتثاقل عن ذلک فیدفعه حتى ینهک بدنه و لو کان إنما یتحرک للجماع بالرغبه فی الولد کان غیر بعید أن یفتر عنه حتى یقل النسل أو ینقطع فإن من الناس من لا یرغب فی الولد و لا یحفل به- فانظر کیف جعل لکل واحد من هذه الأفعال التی بها قوام الإنسان و صلاحه محرکا من نفس الطبع یحرکه لذلک و یحدوه علیه
توحید المفضل، ص: 75
و اعلم أن فی الإنسان قوى أربعا قوه جاذبه تقبل الغذاء و تورده على المعده و قوه ماسکه تحبس الطعام حتى تفعل فیه الطبیعه فعلها و قوه هاضمه و هی التی تطبخه و تستخرج صفوه و تبثه فی البدن و قوه دافعه تدفعه و تحدر الثفل الفاضل بعد أخذ الهاضمه حاجتها ففکر فی تقدیر هذه القوى الأربع التی فی البدن و أفعالها و تقدیرها للحاجه إلیها و الإرب فیها و ما فی ذلک من التدبیر و الحکمه فلو لا الجاذبه کیف کان یتحرک الإنسان لطلب الغذاء الذی به قوام البدن و لو لا الماسکه کیف کان یلبث الطعام فی الجوف حتى تهضمه المعده و لو لا الهاضمه کیف کان ینطبخ حتى یخلص منه الصفو الذی یغذو البدن و یسد خلله «3» و لو لا الدافعه کیف کان الثفل الذی تخلفه الهاضمه یندفع و یخرج أولا فأولا أ فلا ترى کیف وکل الله سبحانه بلطف صنعه و حسن تقدیره هذه القوى بالبدن و القیام بما فیه صلاحه و سأمثل لک فی ذلک مثالا إن البدن بمنزله دار الملک له فیها حشم «4» و صبیه و قوام موکلون بالدار فواحد لقضاء حوائج الحشم و إیرادها علیهم و آخر لقبض ما یرد و خزنه إلى أن یعالج و یهیأ و آخر لعلاج ذلک و تهیئته و تفریقه و آخر لتنظیف ما فی الدار من الأقذار و إخراجه منها فالملک فی هذا هو الخلاق الحکیم ملک العالمین و الدار هی البدن و الحشم هم الأعضاء و القوام هم هذه القوى الأربع و لعلک ترى ذکرنا هذه القوى الأربع و أفعالها بعد الذی وصفت فضلا و تزدادا و لیس ما ذکرته من هذه القوى على الجهه التی ذکرت فی کتب الأطباء و لا قولنا فیه کقولهم لأنهم ذکروها على ما یحتاج إلیه فی صناعه الطب و تصحیح الأبدان و ذکرناها على ما یحتاج فی صلاح الدین و شفاء النفوس من الغی کالذی أوضحته بالوصف الشافی و المثل المضروب من التدبیر و الحکمه فیها
توحید المفضل، ص: 77
#Answer 564 (Part Three)
The faculties of thought, estimation, reason, and memory
O Mufaddal, now that you understand the faculties of the body, reflect on the faculties God Most High has placed in the human soul and the benefits they bring: the faculties of thought, estimation, reason, memory, and others. Consider what a person’s condition would be if memory alone were taken from him. How many disruptions would that cause in his affairs, livelihood, and dealings? He would not remember what he had entrusted to others or what they had entrusted to him, what he had given or received, what he had seen or heard, what he had said or what had been said to him. He would not remember who had treated him well and who had wronged him, or what benefited him and what harmed him. Even if he had traveled a road مرات لا یحصى, he would not recognize it. He would not retain knowledge, even if he studied it all his life; he would hold no religious belief, benefit from no experience, and be unable to learn from anything that had happened in the past. Indeed, such a person would scarcely remain human at all.
Reflect on how the loss of just one of the faculties of the soul would disrupt a person’s life; how much more so if all of them were taken from him.
The Oneness of al-Mufaddal, translated by Allama Majlisi, p. 101
تأمل یا مفضل هذه القوى التی فی النفس و موقعها من الإنسان أعنی الفکر و الوهم و العقل و الحفظ و غیر ذلک أ فرأیت لو نقص الإنسان من هذه الخلال الحفظ وحده کیف کانت تکون حاله و کم من خلل کان یدخل علیه فی أموره و معاشه و تجاربه إذا لم یحفظ ما له و ما علیه و ما أخذه و ما أعطى و ما رأى و ما سمع و ما قال و ما قیل له و لم یذکر من أحسن إلیه ممن أساء به و ما نفعه مما ضره ثم کان لا یهتدی لطریق لو سلکه ما لا یحصى و لا یحفظ علما و لو درسه عمره و لا یعتقد دینا و لا ینتفع بتجربه و لا یستطیع أن یعتبر شیئا على ما مضى بل کان حقیقا أن ینسلخ من الإنسانیه
توحید المفضل، ص: 77
All the questions were raised in the Telegram group Kahf Question and Yaqut Answer, and the answers are by Master Ali Saei.