Is it permissible to speak about one’s personal sins in a gathering in order to overcome blameworthy traits such as self-importance, conceit, and arrogance?
Is It Permissible to Disclose One’s Personal Sins to Overcome Arrogance?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Revealing one’s personal sins to overcome blameworthy traits such as arrogance is itself a serious failing: it brings disgrace and diminishes one’s sense of modesty. True goodwill means discreetly pointing out others’ faults to them, so that once corrected, those faults remain hidden from others. A believer’s duty is to conceal the faults of others.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterTo combat self-conceit and arrogance, one must take the soundest approach. To cleanse a face of grime and filth, one should not injure it.
Revealing someone’s fault is itself a grave fault. Only a specialist physician should perform surgery. A sincere and upright adviser, mindful of the particular sensitivities involved, should privately offer a fellow believer their fault as a gift (أبی عبد الله ع قال: أحب إخوانی إلی من أهدى إلی عیوبی.)
{ ثمره الأخوه حفظ الغیب و إهداء العیب
A sincere adviser points out another’s fault with the intention of removing it and keeping it concealed. To make it public is to expose and disgrace that person! It is a form of violating a believer’s dignity and can erode their sense of modesty.
من بصرک عیبک فقد نصحک
Whoever makes you aware of your fault is wishing you well!
No well-wisher seeks to bring about someone’s disgrace. They speak of a person’s fault to that person alone, and privately, so that once it has been remedied, it can remain hidden from others as well—not so that we might broadcast others’ faults to everyone!
A believer’s duty is to conceal another believer’s faults, not expose them!
من أفشى سرک ضیع أمرک
Whoever discloses your secret has undermined your affairs!
لو عقل المرء عقله لأحرز سره عمن أفشاه إلیه و لم یطلع أحدا علیه
لا تثق بمن یذیع سرک
Do not trust someone who reveals your secret!
لا یستر عبد على عبد فی الدنیا الا ستر الله علیه یوم القیامه
Nahj al-Fasaha (A Collection of the Prophet’s صلى الله علیه و آله Sayings), p. 682
If a servant conceals another servant’s fault in this world, God will conceal his faults on the Day of Resurrection.
من ستر اخاه المسلم فی الدنیا فلم یفضحه ستره الله یوم القیامه.
Whoever conceals his Muslim brother’s fault in this world and does not disgrace him, God will conceal his own fault on the Day of Resurrection.
In the practice of the Imams of the Prophet’s Household, the Infallible and Pure (علیهم السلام), no such approach was used to remedy others’ self-conceit and arrogance.