Peace be upon you. Is it permissible to publicly curse and declare female singers and immoral women unbelievers because of what they do?
Is It Permissible to Publicly Curse and Declare Female Singers and Immoral Women Unbelievers?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
It is permissible to curse people notorious for corruption, but naming them publicly should serve a purpose, such as raising awareness. At times, naming them can cause harm by making the corrupt person more famous, arousing curiosity, and creating mental images that may themselves lead to further wrongdoing. Cursing without mentioning the corrupt person by name is more effective.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterAlthough it is permissible to curse people who are widely known for their corruption, naming them while cursing them should serve a purpose: for example, to alert people to avoid the corrupt individual and warn them of the dangers to their religious life; or to encourage them to disavow and distance themselves from that person, join in cursing the individual in question, and do the same with others like them. Sometimes, however, identifying a corrupt person can itself cause harm in society. It may promote and bring notoriety to that person, or stir people’s interest and curiosity about them—opening a path to corruption for some. This is all the more likely in a society where most people are not committed to religious principles and beliefs.
Naming a corrupt man or woman may also create a mental image of that person, which can itself become a means of enticing people towards corruption.
Sometimes, cursing a corrupt person without mentioning their name is more effective than exposing it—especially when the person has no qualms about their sins and regards their corruption as a source of pride and distinction.