Dear teacher, following on from our discussion of being mistreated by those around us—usually through words such as backbiting, slander and lies, as well as through their behaviour—what should we do when someone deliberately acts this way, perhaps out of sheer spite, to hurt and upset the other person, and repeatedly engages in this ugly behaviour? Are we permitted to cut ties with them in such circumstances?
I previously asked whether we should attend celebrations with relatives and acquaintances who do not observe God’s limits—for example, weddings—in order to avoid severing family ties. You said that maintaining family ties should be for the sake of God’s approval, and that it is not permissible to maintain ties with people who do not observe God’s limits. In light of the issues I have described above, is it permissible to cut ties with relatives? I would be grateful for your guidance. I often feel uncertain in these situations and cannot discern the right course: how can I observe God’s limits without cutting off family ties over these matters? Thank you.
Answer 2700
Maintaining ties with relatives, friends and family members is not permissible if doing so leads one to become involved in sin or wrongdoing, or emboldens those who persist in disobedience.
If, through maintaining these ties, those who persist in disobedience are admonished and advised, and signs of receptiveness, repentance and remorse become evident—or if it helps them lessen their engagement in disliked acts and sins—then it is permissible, provided the person maintaining the ties is not negatively influenced and is safe from other harmful consequences.
When someone’s hurtful behaviour causes emotional or psychological harm, protecting one’s well-being takes precedence. The exception is when, despite the harm and distress, some benefit comes to both parties that outweighs the significant harm.