Is the account of Abraham, peace be upon him, and Zechariah, peace be upon him, sharing in the suffering of Sayyid al-Shuhada authentic?
Is the account of Abraham (AS) and Zechariah (AS) sharing in the suffering of Sayyid al-Shuhada authentic?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Abraham (AS) bled in Karbala because of the tragedy of Imam Hussein, and this occurred by divine permission. This particular act of sharing in his suffering should not be wrongly generalized to justify practices such as qama-zani (striking oneself with a blade). True solidarity in mourning Imam Hussein means turning to the Lord in prayer while taking one’s capacity to endure into account.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThose who seek to share in mourning must be prepared for trials like the tragedy of al-Husayn
It is very important to remember that when the tragedy of the Master of Martyrs, al-Husayn, is recalled, the blood that flowed from Abraham and some of the other prophets, peace be upon them, did not flow by their own doing. Rather, their Creator subjected them to trials that caused some of their blood to be shed.
Some people draw a mistaken conclusion from the fact that certain prophets shared, in a limited way, in a calamity resembling that of the Master of Martyrs, and extend it to the practice of striking oneself with a blade in order to justify it. In doing so, they commit a particular kind of fallacy. Those who wish to share in the grief of mourning for Imam al-Husayn, peace be upon him, should direct their request to the sacred presence of the Lord of the worlds—but first they should assess their ability to bear what they ask for. For perhaps one who seeks to share in that grief must sacrifice his own Ishmael! Or ...
و روی أن إبراهیم ع مر فی أرض کربلاء و هو راکب فرسا فعثرت به و سقط إبراهیم و شج رأسه و سال دمه فأخذ فی الاستغفار و قال إلهی أی شیء حدث منی فنزل إلیه جبرئیل و قال یا إبراهیم ما حدث منک ذنب و لکن هنا یقتل سبط خاتم الأنبیاء و ابن خاتم الأوصیاء فسال دمک موافقه لدمه قال یا جبرئیل و من یکون قاتله قال لعین أهل السماوات و الأرضین و القلم جرى على اللوح بلعنه بغیر إذن ربه فأوحى الله تعالى إلى القلم أنک استحققت الثناء بهذا اللعن فرفع إبراهیم ع یدیه و لعن یزید لعنا کثیرا و أمن فرسه بلسان فصیح فقال إبراهیم لفرسه أی شیء عرفت حتى تؤمن على دعائی فقال یا إبراهیم أنا أفتخر برکوبک علی فلما عثرت و سقطت عن ظهری عظمت خجلتی و کان سبب ذلک من یزید لعنه الله تعالى.
بحار الأنوار (ط - بیروت)، ج44، ص: 243