Peace be upon you, esteemed teacher. Is the account of the sun’s return—one of the miracles and virtues attributed to Imam Ali (AS)—authentic, given that it appears in Sunni sources? Is this hadith considered reliable among the Shia? Thank you.
Is the Account of the Sun’s Return for Imam Ali (AS) Authentic?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The account of the sun’s return for Imam Ali (AS) is widely reported and, given the large number of transmitters across different generations, is considered mutawatir. Similar accounts have also been related about the Prophet (PBUH) and Solomon (AS), and it is seen as a testament to the greatness of Imam Ali (AS).
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe sun is nothing; the universe turns from its course out of respect for Ali (AS)
The hadith of the sun’s return is widely known in the transmitted tradition; moreover, given the many narrators who relate it across different generations, it also reaches the level of mass transmission!
رد له الشمس مره ، وفعل ذلک أیضا للرسول حین نام ورأسه فی حجر علی فانتبه وقد غربت الشمس ، فردها حتى صلى ، وردها مره أخرى لعلی فصلى العصر فی وقته ،
تفسیر الرازی|فخر الدین الرازی|32|606|مصادر تفسیر سنى|||الثالثه||||||-Ahl al-Bayt (AS) Library - Second edition
Tafsir al-Razi – Fakhr al-Din al-Razi – vol. 32 – p. 126
The sun’s return occurred once for Solomon (AS). It also occurred for the Noble Prophet صلى الله علیه و آله when the Messenger of God صلى الله علیه و آله had laid his head in Ali’s lap (AS) and fallen asleep. When he awoke, the sun had set. At the Messenger of God’s صلى الله علیه و آله prayer, the sun returned so that Ali (AS) could perform the afternoon prayer within its prescribed time.
Other sources
و بالنسبه الى رد الشمس لعلى بدعاء النبی حتى صلى صلاه العصر یرجع حد الأقل الى: منتخب کنز العمال (ج 4 ص 291) و المعتصر من المختصر (ج 1 ص 9) و شفاء القاضی عیاض (ج 3 ص 10) و اسعاف الراغبین (ص 162) و ینابیع الموده (ج 1 ص 137) و اللئالئ المصنوعه (ج 1 ص 174) و کفایه الطالب (ص 237) و تذکره الخواص (ص 55).
التفسیر لکتاب الله المنیر، ج8، ص