Peace be upon you, dear and esteemed teacher. My special thanks to you for your three valuable pieces explaining why people should not go bare-chested at gatherings of the Ahl al-Bayt (AS). Teacher, an argument made in favor of going bare-chested during mourning rituals, particularly by Arabs, is this: “الا یا اهل العالم ان جدی الحسین ع سحقوه عریانا” (O people of the world, my grandfather Husayn was crushed naked). Since our master Imam Husayn (AS), after his martyrdom, lay naked in the middle of the land of Karbala beneath the scorching sun, these people prefer to go bare-chested, especially during mourning rituals for Imam Husayn (AS). How should we respond to this claim?
Is the Argument for Going Bare-Chested in Mourning Valid?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The Imams (AS) did not teach that mourners should go bare-chested to recall a particular moment in Imam Husayn’s (AS) martyrdom. Even in his final moments, he sought to keep himself covered, and reenacting that scene is disrespectful to him. Showing such scenes encourages further disrespect toward his sacred person and normalizes the enormity of the tragedy.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterWe should remember that mourning for the Master of the Martyrs, peace be upon him, has rules and principles set out by his pure descendants—the Imams of the Household, peace be upon them. Yet no instruction to bare the body in remembrance of that particular moment has ever issued from any of those holy figures.
The words and actions of an Infallible can serve as proof for our own actions. Imam Husayn, peace be upon him, strove to keep himself clothed until his final moments. We, too, must remain committed to preserving this sanctity.
ائتونی بثوب لا یرغب فیه ألبسه غیر ثیابی
Any reenactment of the scene is a kind of disrespect toward the Imam, for he tried to ensure that his sacred body would not be left bare. Staging such scenes amounts to repeating that disrespect. The events should be recounted only by allusion, so that the Imam’s inviolable dignity, honour and rank remain untouched.
Certainly, if the exposure of his blessed body did take place, no impure eye could have seen that pure body—لا یمسه الا المطهرون. Therefore, the scene should not be reenacted openly, adding to the audacity of the act.
Reenacting the scene harms the incomparable culture of mourning for the Imam. Speaking plainly about certain events, or explicitly restaging certain scenes, diminishes the intensity and magnitude of the tragedy and makes it seem ordinary in people’s minds.
It is not possible to recreate the events and calamities that befell the Imam. The fervent love and surging anger that his devotees feel toward his killers must be preserved in their hearts like a trust, so that on the day of true vengeance it may burst forth at the side of the Master of the Age, the Imam of our time, and at his command.
Explicit references to the events of Ashura extinguish the fire of grief, whereas the flame of that grief should burn ever brighter until the day of vengeance.
Surely, the Imam did not approve of being stripped bare; therefore, we must avoid doing what he would have disliked.
The Master of the Martyrs, peace be upon him, was the Face of God. There is no doubt that immense calamities befell him, but this does not mean that God, the Severe in Punishment, gave permission for every act of desecration. The angels themselves have no permission to see the Imam’s sanctified body—how much less the eyes of the wretched.
We must not act in ways that lead others to imagine that the Imam of the Martyrs was an ordinary person, that the wicked were free to commit any outrage against him, or that certain outrages actually took place, or that unworthy eyes fell upon his blessed body. Surely, when the wicked turn their eyes toward him, they are struck blind. Imam Husayn, peace be upon him, is a part of the very being of the Lady of all Women; on the Day of Resurrection, when she passes toward the Abode of Paradise, the eyes of all those gathered will be lowered.
It might be no surprise if people’s eyes were to behold the sun’s veiled light; but for their eyes to fall upon the pure, sanctified and naked body of the Imam is utterly impossible. There is no doubt about this.
Al-A‘raf 198: و إن تدعوهم إلى الهدى لا یسمعوا و تراهم ینظرون إلیک و هم لا یبصرون
If you call them to guidance, they do not hear. You see them looking toward you, yet they do not see.
Yunus 43: و منهم من ینظر إلیک أ فأنت تهدی العمی و لو کانوا لا یبصرون
Some of them look toward you. Can you guide the blind, even though they cannot see?
Ya Sin 9: و جعلنا من بین أیدیهم سدا و من خلفهم سدا فأغشیناهم فهم لا یبصرون
We have set a barrier before them and a barrier behind them, and covered them over, so that they cannot see.
Muhammad 23: أولئک الذین لعنهم الله فأصمهم و أعمى أبصارهم
Those are the ones whom God has cursed, making them deaf and blinding their eyes.
It hardly needs to be said that the spirits of the Shi‘a are from the bodies of the Imams, and the bodies of the Imams are from Illiyyin. Thus, only the eyes of those from Illiyyin are worthy of seeing their blessed bodies—let alone their incomparable stature. The bodies and spirits of the unbelievers, by contrast, are from Sijjin, and have their own allotted place.
عن أبی الحجاج قال: قال لی أبو جعفر ع یا أبا الحجاج إن الله خلق محمدا و آل محمد من طینه علیین و خلق قلوبهم من طینه فوق ذلک و خلق شیعتنا من طینه دون علیین و خلق قلوبهم من طینه علیین فقلوب شیعتنا من أبدان آل محمد و إن الله خلق عدو آل محمد من طین سجین و خلق قلوبهم من طین أخبث من ذلک و خلق شیعتهم من طین دون طین سجین و خلق قلوبهم من طین سجین فقلوبهم من أبدان أولئک و کل قلب یحن إلى بدنه.
بصائر الدرجات فی فضائل آل محمد صلى الله علیهم، ج1، ص: 14