Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 1147 20 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Is the Classification of the Spirit in Classical Medical Texts Correct?

Primary reference: See the answer text 40 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-1147

سلام علیکم ⁉ Esteemed teacher, is this kind of classification, found in old medical texts, correct? ⁉

**Spirits**

Another component of the natural faculties is the spirits. *Arwāḥ* is the plural of *rūḥ*, and in medicine it has a meaning different from the one commonly understood.

In humoral medicine, spirits are subtle bodies produced from the vapours of the humours. They are subtle, fluid and mobile.

The medical spirit is a subtle substance, distinct from the religious spirit, which some philosophers have called the rational soul.

Some books state that there is an affinity between the medical spirit and the religious spirit, like the bond between spouses. As long as this bond remains strong, the body is alive and awake. When fatigue and exhaustion weaken it, sleep occurs; and if the bond is severed altogether, the body deteriorates and death follows.

**How the medical spirit is generated**

When blood enters the left ventricle of the heart, it matures and becomes subtle. Some of its constituents are transformed into a subtle vapour: this is the spirit.

Thus, the spirit is generated from the humours; it is not inhaled from the air. Accordingly, eating strengthens the spirit, while a lack of food weakens it.

Spirits may be regarded as carriers of the faculties: they convey them from the organ of origin to the organ they act upon. At the same time, however, the movement of the spirit is itself brought about by the faculty.

**Classification of the medical spirit**

**Natural spirit:** Its seat is the liver. It contributes to nutrition, growth and development. From the liver, it reaches throughout the body by way of the veins.

**Psychic spirit:** Its seat is the brain. It plays a role in sensation, movement and governance, and reaches all the organs from the brain by way of the nerves.

**Vital spirit:** Its seat is the heart. It spreads throughout the body through the arteries. Its function is to bring fresh air and carry away the vapours of the organs. It also plays a role in fear and anger.

Please remember me in your prayers.

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

In classical medical texts, the spirit is understood as a breath, gas, or vapor produced by the body’s humors. This is distinct from the spirit as understood in religious teachings—the rational soul. This medical spirit carries the faculties and is generated from blood and air. These texts classify it as natural (associated with the liver), psychic (associated with the brain), and vital (associated with the heart). But human life in its true sense comes from the divine breath, and this classification has no connection to it.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

Their understanding of the spirit goes back to the literal meaning of the word: wind, or, in other words, gas or vapour. In their view, the refinement and distillation of blood can sometimes cause gases to rise, and they consider the substances or elements that make up these gases to come from within the body. In other words, they regard the relationship among the body’s four humours as a factor in producing the spirit they have in mind.

The body’s internal organs and limbs have particular connections with its inward faculties, but these connections have nothing to do with the classification mentioned above. For example, the body’s pineal-shaped heart is connected to a person’s inward heart (the *del*), which is the principal centre of feelings and bodily connections. This faculty is closely connected with روح البدن, and the brain may in some sense be associated with روح القوه. For instance, روح القوه may depart from the body, as in brain death; or روح البدن may depart from the body, as in a heart attack, even though brain death may not yet have occurred, in which case the body may still be revived. But what constitutes a person’s true life is the divine breath,

Subtle faculty

For general information, and to illustrate the connection between the bodily organs and limbs and the inward organs:

العقل من القلب و الحزن من الکبد و النفس من الریه و الضحک من الطحال فقمت و قبلت رأسه.
کفایه الأثر فی النص على الأئمه الإثنی عشر، ص: 254

روی أن أمیر المؤمنین ع مر بسوق القصابین فنهاهم عن بیع أشیاء منها الطحال فقیل ما الکبد و الطحال إلا سواء فقال ع له کذبت ایتنی بتورین من ماء «1» أنبئک بخلاف ما تقول فأتی بطحال و کبد و تورین من ماء فقال شق الکبد من وسطه و الطحال من وسطه و اجعلهما فی الماء جمیعا ففعل فلم ینقص من الکبد شیئا و صار الطحال کله دما و هی جلد و عروق فقال هذا لحم و هذا دم.
فقه القرآن، ج‏2، ص: 260

Liver

The liver is the body’s largest gland and plays a role in metabolic processes such as digestion.

All the blood from the digestive system is collected by a vein called the portal vein and carried to the liver. All the substances absorbed from the digestive tract pass through the liver. The liver also traps toxins and purifies them by converting them into harmless substances. It is also responsible for metabolising drugs in the body. Other functions of the liver include producing blood cells before birth, resisting infections, rapidly supplying energy when needed, and storing iron.

Research indicates that reduced liver function can cause depression. When insufficient nutrients pass through the liver and reach the cells, the cells become deficient and cannot function properly. This, in turn, brings a person sadness and sorrow. In addition, when nutrients accumulate in the liver and become stagnant, they putrefy and spoil, which is itself a major cause of sadness and sorrow.

عذاب الملوک الظاهره القادره فی الدنیا و ثوابه أفضل من ثوابها فأما عذابه فالحزن و أما ثوابه فالفرح و أصل الحزن فی الطحال و أصل الفرح فی الثرب «1» و الکلیتین و فیهما عرقان موصلان فی الوجه فمن هناک یظهر الفرح و الحزن فترى تباشیرهما فی الوجه و هذه العروق کلها طرق من العمال إلى الملک «2» و من الملک إلى العمال و تصدیق ذلک إذا تناول الدواء أدته العروق إلى موضع الداء.
طب الإمام الرضا علیه السلام (الرساله الذهبیه)، النص، ص: 13

In addition to the pleasure and distress this sovereign experiences through its aides and agents, the authority bestowed upon it also brings rewards and punishments commensurate with its deeds. Its punishment is more severe than that of the mighty, visible rulers of the world, and its reward greater than theirs. Its punishment is sorrow, and its reward joy and happiness.

Sorrow originates in the spleen, while joy and happiness originate in the kidneys and the omentum. Two veins connect the kidneys to the face; through them, joy and sorrow become apparent, and their signs can be seen on the face.

## The Liver, the Body’s Physician

When the liver is restored to health, the body itself treats all its known and unknown illnesses.

## The Spleen

The spleen is an important organ, yet in many ways it remains poorly understood, and not all of its functions are fully known. It is about the size of a person’s fist and lies in the upper-left part of the abdomen, between the stomach and the diaphragm, roughly beneath the ribs. It is dark purple in colour. The ribs protect it from injury.

The spleen is located in the upper-left part of the abdomen. As part of the immune system, it produces and stores blood cells, and is also considered part of the circulatory system.

## The Functions of the Spleen

1. **Filtering the blood**

The spleen’s first and most important function is to filter the blood, a role similar to one performed by the liver. The spleen cleans the blood, identifying damaged red blood cells and removing them from the bloodstream.

2. **Recycling blood**

3. **Storing blood**

The spleen keeps a reserve of blood so that it can release it when the body needs it because of injury, trauma or illness.

4. **Protecting the body’s immunity**

The spleen plays a key role in the functioning of the immune system. As it filters the blood, it removes red blood cells damaged by infection.

5. **Producing lymphocytes (white blood cells)**

Without white blood cells, people cannot fight infection and bacteria.

White blood cells also help repair damaged parts of the body.

The spleen also works with the lymph glands to produce lymphocytes, enabling the body to fight bacteria and viruses.

Distress and depression (melancholy, or black bile) are the main causes of this illness. Stress, unpleasant events, noise pollution, and the problems and difficulties of everyday life are among its causes. In terms of diet, too, if a person eats sour foods after distress, stress and the like, black bile may then predominate in the body, and the person may develop these symptoms. The source of this illness is the spleen. The spleen is an organ in which certain necessary acids accumulate. After the stomach has emptied, some of this acid is sent to the stomach, and the person feels hungry. But if the person is suddenly and unexpectedly confronted with something upsetting, the acid affects the blood. Since blood circulates throughout the body, when it reaches the brain the person feels worry, fear, agitation, apprehension, anxiety and stress. At first this may be mistaken for nervous weakness; the person becomes easily upset and depressed, and is more prone to crying. The complexion gradually darkens. Treatment should not be delayed.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022