Greetings, esteemed teacher. Please explain the realm of the grave and the punishment specific to it. What is the purpose of the scorpions and snakes of the grave, and why are they sent into a person’s grave? Can a body without a soul feel the stings of scorpions and snakes? And if someone is a believer, what will their experience in the grave be like? Is it not the case that after death a person enters the paradise or hell of the barzakh? If so, is there still a period of waiting in the realm of the grave? Please explain. Thank you.
Is the Punishment of the Grave Physical or Spiritual?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Death means the soul’s departure from the body of this world and its entry into the barzakh body. The punishment of the grave is inflicted on the barzakh body, while the constriction of the grave refers to the narrowness of the barzakh dwelling. The paradise and hell of the barzakh are distinct from the paradise and hell of the hereafter, and good and evil deeds take embodied form as images in the barzakh.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterDeath in this world means the soul’s departure from the earthly realm: it leaves the worldly body and enters an imaginal, or barzakhī, body. The body is left behind. Thus, what dies is the human being’s physical body, while what comes to life is the human being’s barzakhī body. With earthly death, then, barzakhī life begins, and barzakhī perception begins as well. Whatever affliction befalls the human body will cause no pain or suffering at the level of sensation, since the worldly body’s nervous system is no longer alive and it has no receiver for sensations. If the soul is affected because of its worldly body, that effect is like the distress one feels when one’s clothes are torn.
The human being’s material nervous system has ceased to function, but the barzakhī nervous system becomes active in the barzakhī body. Thus, the serpents and scorpions of the barzakh will assail the barzakhī bodies of evildoers, and their hearts and souls will suffer, while the righteous will enjoy the blessings of the barzakh in happiness and ease.
The torment of the grave is, in reality, torment inflicted on the barzakhī body. The narrowness or spaciousness of the grave is, in reality, the narrowness or spaciousness of one’s abode in the barzakh.
A person’s good and bad deeds will take visible form as images and barzakhī bodies. Human deeds will appear in imaginal forms.
When hadith books speak of the realm of the grave, they mean the barzakhī realm, not the physical grave.
فقال الصادق ع البرزخ القبر و فیه الثواب و العقاب بین الدنیا و الآخره
Tafsīr al-Qummī, vol. 1, p. 19
Imam al-Ṣādiq, peace be upon him, said: “The barzakh is the grave. In it there are reward and punishment, and it lies between this world and the Hereafter.”
We must be mindful of our barzakh. Deliverance from the barzakh strengthens our hope for salvation in the Hereafter.
قول الصادق ع و الله ما أخاف علیکم إلا البرزخ- فأما إذا صار الأمر إلینا فنحن أولى بکم
Imam al-Ṣādiq, peace be upon him, said: “By God, I fear nothing for you except the barzakh. But when the matter comes into our hands, we have a greater claim to you.”
The barzakhī Paradise and Hell are distinct from the Paradise and Hell of the Hereafter.
و قال علی بن الحسین ع إن القبر روضه من ریاض الجنه أو حفره من حفر النیران
Tafsīr al-Qummī, vol. 2, p. 94
Imam al-Sajjād, peace be upon him, said: “The grave is either a garden among the gardens of Paradise, or a pit among the pits of Hell.”
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج3، ص: 244
After death, the souls of the believers are placed in bodies like their physical bodies.
عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: قلت له جعلت فداک یروون أن أرواح المؤمنین فی حواصل طیور خضر حول العرش فقال لا المؤمن أکرم على الله من أن یجعل روحه فی حوصله طیر و لکن فی أبدان کأبدانهم.
Dār al-Salām is the barzakhī Paradise, and Barahūt is the barzakhī Hell.
عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: قلت له إن أخی ببغداد و أخاف أن یموت بها فقال ما تبالی حیثما مات أما إنه لا یبقى مؤمن فی شرق الأرض و غربها إلا حشر الله روحه إلى وادی السلام قلت له و أین وادی السلام قال ظهر الکوفه أما إنی کأنی بهم حلق حلق قعود یتحدثون.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج3، ص: 244
2- A group of our companions, from Sahl ibn Ziyād, from ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn Abī Najrān, from Muthannā al-Ḥannāṭ, from Abū Baṣīr, who said: Abū ʿAbd Allāh said: “The souls of the believers are in a tree in Paradise. They eat of its fruits and drink of its drink, and say: ‘Our Lord, bring the Hour upon us, fulfil what You promised us, and reunite those who come after us with those who came before us.’”
عن أبی بصیر عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: سألته عن أرواح المشرکین فقال فی النار یعذبون یقولون ربنا لا تقم لنا الساعه و لا تنجز لنا ما وعدتنا و لا تلحق آخرنا بأولنا.
2- A group of our companions, from Sahl ibn Ziyād, from ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn Abī Najrān, from Muthannā, from Abū Baṣīr, from Abū ʿAbd Allāh, who said: “The souls of the unbelievers are in the Fire of Hell, exposed to it. They say: ‘Our Lord, do not bring the Hour upon us, do not fulfil what You promised us, and do not reunite those who come after us with those who came before us.’”
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج3، ص: 246
ن محمد بن أحمد بإسناد له قال قال أمیر المؤمنین ع شر بئر فی النار برهوت «1» الذی فیه أرواح الکفار.
عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: ما من موضع قبر إلا و هو ینطق کل یوم ثلاث مرات أنا بیت التراب أنا بیت البلاء أنا بیت الدود قال فإذا دخله عبد مؤمن قال مرحبا و أهلا أما و الله لقد کنت أحبک و أنت تمشی على ظهری فکیف إذا دخلت بطنی فسترى ذلک قال فیفسح له مد البصر و یفتح له باب یرى مقعده من الجنه قال و یخرج من ذلک رجل لم تر عیناه شیئا قط أحسن منه فیقول یا عبد الله ما رأیت شیئا قط أحسن منک فیقول أنا رأیک الحسن الذی کنت علیه و عملک الصالح الذی کنت تعمله قال ثم تؤخذ روحه فتوضع فی الجنه حیث رأى منزله ثم یقال له نم قریر العین فلا یزال نفحه من الجنه تصیب جسده یجد لذتها و طیبها حتى یبعث قال و إذا دخل الکافر قال لا مرحبا بک و لا أهلا أما و الله لقد کنت أبغضک و أنت تمشی على ظهری فکیف إذا دخلت بطنی سترى ذلک قال فتضم علیه فتجعله رمیما و یعاد کما کان و یفتح له باب إلى النار فیرى مقعده من النار ثم قال ثم إنه یخرج منه رجل أقبح من رأى قط قال فیقول یا عبد الله من أنت ما رأیت شیئا أقبح منک قال فیقول أنا عملک السیئ الذی کنت تعمله و رأیک الخبیث قال ثم تؤخذ روحه فتوضع حیث رأى مقعده من النار ثم لم تزل نفخه من النار تصیب جسده فیجد ألمها و حرها فی جسده إلى یوم یبعث و یسلط الله على روحه تسعه و تسعین «1» تنینا تنهشه لیس فیها تنین ینفخ على ظهر الأرض فتنبت شیئا.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج3، ص: 241
Imam al-Sadiq (AS) said: “There is no grave that does not speak three times each day, saying, ‘I am the home of dust. I am the home of decay. I am the home of worms.’
“Every grave says this each day. When a believing servant enters the grave, it says to him, ‘Welcome! By God Almighty, I loved you when you walked upon the earth; now that you have entered me, I love you all the more. Before long, you will see what awaits you here.’
“Then his resting place expands as far as the eye can see, and a door opens for him through which he sees his place in Paradise. From that very door emerges someone whose like in beauty his eyes have never beheld. He says to this beautiful figure, ‘Servant of God, I have never seen anything more beautiful than you. Who are you?’ The figure replies, ‘I am the good belief you held in this world—“انا رأیک الحسن الذی کنت علیه”—and the good deed you used to perform—“و عملک الصالح الذی کنت تعمله”.’
“Then the soul of the believing servant is taken and placed in Paradise, in the very place he had seen. He is told, ‘Rest in complete peace and comfort.’ A gentle breeze from Paradise continually reaches his body, and he enjoys its sweetness and goodness until the day he is raised.”
The Imam (AS) continued: “When a disbeliever enters the grave, it says to him, ‘May you find no welcome! By God Almighty, I loathed you when you walked upon the earth. How will it be now that you have entered me? Before long, you will see.’
“Then the grave presses him until it crushes him into tiny particles, after which he is restored to his former state. A door opens for him toward the Fire, and he sees his place there. From that same door emerges someone of a vileness no one has ever seen before. He says to this loathsome figure, ‘Servant of God, who are you? I have never seen anything more loathsome than you!’ The figure replies, ‘I am your evil deeds, which you used to perform, and your impure belief and judgment.’
“The Imam (AS) said: ‘Then his soul is taken and placed in the very place he had seen for himself in the Fire. A burning heat continually reaches his body, and he feels its pain and scorching until the Day of Resurrection. God Almighty appoints ninety-nine enormous serpents over him, which bite him. If even one of them were to breathe upon the earth, the earth would never again bring forth a thing.’”