Hello, Ustad Saei. Is the image above correct? (#FatimiyyaDays)
Is the text in the image about the Fatimiyya days accurate?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The disagreement over the date of Lady Fatimah’s (SA) martyrdom stems from the fact that punctuation was not commonly used in narrations, as well as from differing interpretations. The first Fatimiyya days (13–15 Jumada al-Awwal) are based on the report that she passed away 75 days after the Prophet (PBUH), while the second Fatimiyya days (3–5 Jumada al-Thani) are based on the report that she passed away 95 days after his passing. Together, these observances span six days, and each has a basis in a narration.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterOne reason for the disagreement over the date of Lady Zahra’s martyrdom may be that dots were not routinely used to distinguish letters in words when the reports were transmitted. The similarity between «خمسه و سبعون» and «خمسه تسعون» supports this possibility.
There are also various other reasons. For example, some people hold sermons and mourning gatherings during the first few days around the earlier proposed date—five or ten days, for instance—while others, given their particular circumstances, prefer to observe the second Fatimiyya period. Some commemorate both periods.
There are different reports concerning the date of حضرت زهرا (SA)’s martyrdom, ranging from forty days to six months after the Prophet’s passing (PBUH). Among Shi‘i scholars, two dates are especially well known and widely accepted: seventy-five days after the Prophet’s passing (PBUH), and ninety-five days.
Since the Prophet of Islam (PBUH) passed away on the twenty-eighth of Safar, the seventy-five-day report places حضرت زهرا (SA)’s martyrdom on the thirteenth to fifteenth of Jumada al-Ula. These days are known as the First Fatimiyya. According to the ninety-five-day report, however, حضرت زهرا (SA)’s martyrdom fell on the third to fifth of Jumada al-Thani; these days are known as the Second Fatimiyya.
Thus, the Fatimiyya observances last six days in total: three days in Jumada al-Ula and three in Jumada al-Thani. The First Fatimiyya falls from the thirteenth to the fifteenth of Jumada al-Ula, and the Second Fatimiyya from the third to the fifth of Jumada al-Thani.
It seems that three days in each month are given as possible dates for her martyrdom because the lunar months between the Prophet’s passing (PBUH) and حضرت زهرا (SA)’s martyrdom may have had twenty-nine days. If the preceding months were complete, however, the date of her martyrdom would be the thirteenth of Jumada al-Ula or the third of Jumada al-Thani.
This is because, according to the calendar, no more than three twenty-nine-day lunar months and no more than four thirty-day lunar months can occur consecutively.
In common usage, however, the second ten days of Jumada al-Ula—from the tenth to the twentieth—are called the First Fatimiyya, since, according to the seventy-five-day report, the martyrdom of that noble Lady fell within this period. The first ten days of Jumada al-Thani—from the first to the tenth—are called the Second Fatimiyya, since, according to the ninety-five-day report, حضرت زهرا سلاماللهعلیها’s martyrdom fell within that period.
Historical sources differ on how long the Noble and Pure Lady remained alive after her father’s passing. Some historians, such as Ya‘qubi, give forty days; others, such as Aisha, daughter of Abu Bakr, give six months; and still others say eight months.
Among these accounts, the reports transmitted from the Imams of Guidance علیهم السلام are the ones we regard as authoritative. As the late Allama Majlisi relates, the late Abu’l-Faraj Isfahani expressed the following view in his book Maqatil al-Talibiyyin: “The length of time Fatima Zahra سلام الله علیها lived after the Prophet صلی الله علیه وآله passed away is disputed. The shortest period given is forty days and the longest is eight months. What is established and accepted among us, however, is the report transmitted from Imam Baqir علیه السلام, who says: ‘Indeed, the Lady of the Greatest Truth سلام الله علیها passed away three months after the passing of the Noble Prophet of Islam صلی الله علیه و آله.’”
Likewise, the late Shi‘i historian Tabari, in his book Dala’il al-Imama, transmits through his chain of narrators reports from Imam Sadiq علیه السلام, who says that the Noble and Pure Lady علیها السلام passed away on a Tuesday in the month of Jumada al-Akhirah, three days into the month, in the year 11 AH.
These two reports form the basis adopted by most Shi‘i scholars, including Sayyid Ibn Tawus in his esteemed book Iqbal.
A second group of sound reports, however, gives the period as seventy-five days. One such report is transmitted by the late Kulayni from Imam Sadiq علیه السلام, who says: “Indeed, Fatima علیه السلام remained in this world for seventy-five days after her noble father.” These reports, too, became the basis for the view held by some Shi‘i scholars, including the late Kulayni.
Al-Kafi: الکافی ولدت فاطمه ع بعد مبعث النبی ص بخمس سنین و توفیت و لها ثمانی عشره سنه و خمسه و سبعون یوما بقیت بعد أبیها خمسه و سبعین یوما.
بحار الأنوار (ط - بیروت)، ج43، ص: 8