Please excuse me, esteemed teacher. I have been comparing the views of some eminent religious scholars on the theory of the unity of being with that of Mulla Sadra. Each used a particular approach and method to explain it. I will not mention names, but one scholar’s view seemed logical to me. Is the theory false at its very foundation, or do its different interpretations affect whether the original theory is false?
Is the Theory of the Unity of Being Fundamentally False?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The theory of the unity of being is acceptable so long as no commonality is posited between the being of God Most High and the being of created things. But if we believe that the Creator’s being is the same as that of the created, the legitimacy of discussing the unity of being comes into question, for God is too exalted to be described in terms of being.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterSo long as no commonality of kind is posited between the existence of God Most High and the existence of creatures, one may take a charitable view of this theory. But if they do not believe the truth that “the Creator’s existence, though expressed by the word ‘existence,’ is far too exalted to be described or expressed in terms of existence,” then every word used of Allah must be accompanied by a declaration of His greatness: «الله اکبر». Any attempt to establish an ontological kinship between Allah’s existence and the existence of creatures calls into question the legitimacy of discussing وحدت وجود.