Could Adam’s descent—which outwardly seemed like a loss of rank and status—be understood as a form of spiritual growth, a journey toward attaining exalted stations? Or did we lose those exalted stations only to regain them through hardship? If the descent had not taken place, what would our circumstances have been?
Was Adam’s Descent a Form of Spiritual Growth?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Adam’s descent was a punishment, but he was also given guidance and a path back to his former station—and even to a higher one. Had the descent not taken place, humanity would still have undergone the trial of servanthood, though the form and substance of that trial would have been different.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterAdam’s descent was certainly a lowering of his rank and a punishment for him and Eve—and for their erring descendants. Yet it was not a descent into a dead-end alley of eternal deprivation. Along with it, they were given a plan of guidance and a path back to their former station—and even to one higher than before.
Had Adam and Eve not approached the forbidden tree, they would have continued from where they were on their journey toward the exalted stations of servitude to God. But by transgressing and eating the fruit of the forbidden tree, they fell from that lofty station. The merciful, compassionate, forgiving Creator, who accepts repentance, nevertheless opened a new path before them—a way to continue their journey of devotion, progress, advancement and spiritual perfection.
We may suppose that if the descent had not taken place and Adam had not approached the forbidden tree, there would have been no knowledge of this world or of its hardships and sufferings. But this would in no way have closed off the path of testing and trial: humanity would certainly still have had to undergo the test of servitude to God, though the form of the test and its questions would have been different.
Taha 20:123: قال اهبطا منها جمیعا بعضکم لبعض عدو فإما یأتینکم منی هدى فمن اتبع هدای فلا یضل و لا یشقى
(God) said, “Go down from it, both of you, as enemies to one another. Then, when guidance comes to you from Me, whoever follows My guidance will neither go astray nor suffer.”