Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 945 4 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

What Are the Conditions for Critique?

Primary reference: See the answer text 18 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Critique requires skill, a thorough command of the subject, sound evidence, careful reflection, and the ability to defend one’s assessment. It should not be driven by emotion, rely on sweeping generalisations, or serve as a way to excuse shortcomings. Critics should also acknowledge the strengths of what they are assessing—and be willing to accept criticism themselves.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

Criticism, too, has its own rules and principles!

Criticism is like surgery. If someone is unfamiliar with the medical and surgical arts and lacks the necessary experience, they will act like an executioner!

But in the hands of someone knowledgeable and experienced, a sharp blade becomes an instrument of treatment and healing!

A critic is a judge in the fullest sense: their judgment may be just or unjust. A judge must be skilled in the art of judgment, and their decisions must not be driven by emotion but grounded in evidence!

A book critic must know the book inside out, having carefully read it from the introduction and table of contents to the very last page. Only then should they critique the work, with full attention and care!

Hasty criticism may take aim at a work’s strengths and, unintentionally, obstruct what is good!

Reflection is essential to every critique, every work, and every action; otherwise, like an inexperienced driver, it will send the critic plunging into a ravine.

A critic must be able to defend their critique; otherwise, it will be an ineffective remedy—or perhaps a deadly poison!

A critic must be willing to have their own criticisms examined; that is, criticism of the critic must itself be subject to criticism!

Vague generalities have no place in criticism. Its specific examples and components must be clearly identified, or else it will only cause confusion!

A critic must not use criticism to cover up broken promises or to justify their own shortcomings, nor turn it into a tool for making themselves appear to be in the right!

In a critique, the strengths of the subject must also be considered, and, in the end, the subject should be given a score.

If the critic’s intention is قربه الی الله, they should have no fear of the response of the person being criticized or of the consequences of their critique.

******************************************************************

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022