Peace be upon you. Could you please say more about the silence mentioned in the text above? What does this silence include? Is it simply a matter of refraining from backbiting, slander, and other sins of the tongue? And how can we strike a balance in remaining silent so that we do not become isolated, while still attaining this desirable kind of silence? In my view, we should trace the motives behind sins of the tongue to their roots and eliminate them. Otherwise, a person will reveal their true state in particular situations and settings, even if they have soothed themselves by keeping silent. Some people, moreover, have always been quiet by nature. Is that alone enough to count as choosing silence? How can such people attain a true understanding of silence, and what do you mean by keeping watch over the self? I would be grateful if you could explain.
What Does True Silence Mean, and How Can We Maintain a Balance?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Speech should spring from the wellspring of knowledge and wisdom; otherwise, it is better to remain silent. We should speak with the intention of drawing closer to God and seeking His pleasure, under the guidance of reason. Wise words should be timely, fitting, and beneficial, and offered to those who are ready to receive them—except in particular circumstances, when they are needed to make the truth clear.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterIn general, speech should spring from the wellspring of knowledge and wisdom; otherwise, one should choose silence!
One should speak with the intention of drawing near to الله and attaining His pleasure!
Speech must be governed by reason; without reason’s guidance, speaking is not permissible!
Any words that do not proceed by way of reason are ignorant, however wise and learned they may seem!
Wise and learned words should be offered at the right time and in the right place; otherwise, even such words should be withheld!
Wise and learned words should be of benefit. If their worth is diminished by an ungrateful lack of receptiveness, one should refrain from offering them! Words should be given, like jewels, to those worthy of them!
At certain times, however, even if one’s words are met with indifference, one must pour them forth and be willing to sacrifice for the sake of admonition, counsel, and establishing the proof!