#FollowUpToQuestion2207
Ustad, if possible, could you explain this further? Some people say, “What’s wrong with these jokes? The hadiths only forbid jokes that lead to harmful consequences; these jokes are nothing like that.”
Ustad, what harm can ordinary jokes cause that they have been discouraged?
What effect does joking with a non-mahram have, even when there is no risk of temptation?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Any unnecessary interaction with a non-mahram—even seemingly harmless joking—can foster warmth and closeness and gradually lead to more dangerous situations. Conversation creates a bond, and joking, however innocent it may seem, can deepen that bond. Emotional intimacy can pave the way for physical intimacy.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterAny unnecessary interaction with a non-mahram woman fosters warmth and intimacy and, gradually and imperceptibly, can lead to dangerous stages over time.
Conversation is a means of connection, and joking—even when seemingly harmless—intensifies that connection; with a non-mahram, it can develop even more quickly.
The bond between hearts is the source of physical intimacy; it begins in the heart. Joking can foster emotional closeness and lead to dangerous consequences.
Unnecessary interaction with a non-mahram is not approved by the Sacred Law, so we should comply with its guidance without resistance or rationalisation.