What is the concept of essence? Can our mental conception and understanding of beings and things be called their essence?
What Is Essence?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Essence may be understood in terms of how beings are apprehended through divine determination. Divine determination is the Creator’s act of defining the bounds of beings; it is real, not merely conceptual or mental. When God’s will and decree bring a being into existence, the essence of that phenomenon comes to be.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterWe may understand quiddity as the way beings apprehend divine determination. Our apprehension of that determination—or its manifestation through things—may be called the quiddity of things. Divine determination is the Creator’s delineation of the bounds of all beings.
When the divine will and determination turn toward bringing a being into existence, the essence of that phenomenon comes to be. The manifestation of divine will through the essence of each being is our apprehension of that being’s existence.
The status of a phenomenon’s quiddity, and its relation to its existence, is like the relation between divine will and divine determination.
In the realm of apprehension, beings can reach no further than the summit of divine will; it is impossible for human beings to advance beyond it. Thus, beings cannot comprehend or even discuss the existence of the Lord. Of course, we use the word “existence” for the divine essence only because we have no alternative: our understanding cannot reach beyond existence. His existence is beyond existence; if we ascribe existence to Him, it is «لیس کمثله وجود». Those who hold to the unity of existence and place the Creator’s existence along the same continuum as all existence, at its summit and highest rank, are unaware of this truth: the human mind reaches an impasse at divine will in its attempt to comprehend existence. All creatures move and strive, understand and reflect, within the divine act—not beyond it. Moreover, no created being can apprehend divine will; this is the province of the angels nearest to God, the messengers sent by Him, and the faithful believers tested and proven in faith.
Quiddity cannot be merely a mental construct or a matter of convention. If we were to strip a being of its bounds, constraints and dimensions of existence—which constitute its quiddity—its very existence would fall apart. Divine determination is real, and in each being it is that being’s quiddity. The minds of beings, too, are places of analysis. The mind’s processing of the quiddities of things does not mean that beings are confined to the mental realm. Nor are mental images merely conventional: mental concepts, too, have a mental quiddity, just as an object and its image do.