Peace be upon you. More attempts to sow doubts and wage war against Imam Husayn عليه السلام by the Yazidists of our time:
They say:
⏪ Was Imam Husayn’s uprising for the caliphate rather than the Imamate?
⏪ They bring up the story of Uraynab (a romantic rivalry), claiming that Yazid wanted revenge on Imam Husayn عليه السلام for that reason.
⏪ Can those who call themselves Imam Husayn’s dog and hold ceremonies in that spirit justify their actions?
What Is Meant by Excess in Imam al-Mahdi’s (AJ) Vengeance?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Imam al-Mahdi’s (AJ) vengeance for the blood of Imam Husayn (AS) may involve the return of his killers and their being put to death again, or the punishment of Yazid’s followers and those who embody Yazidi traits. Likewise, displays of humility such as calling oneself Imam Husayn’s (AS) dog strike at the school of the Ahl al-Bayt and are not pleasing to them. True devotion should instead be accompanied by the cultivation of every virtue and observance of God’s laws.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterPart One
⏪Was Imam Husayn’s uprising about the caliphate rather than the imamate?
Those who sow doubts—and are worse than the followers of Yazid and allies of Satan—fail to understand the difference between the imamate and the caliphate, and claim that the Imam’s uprising was about attaining the caliphate. Yet the Infallible Imams were both Imams and successors to the Messenger of God. Striving to establish an indisputable right is not merely unobjectionable; it is a virtue in its own right, since it is necessary to establish a government founded on justice. What is ugly and blameworthy is the love of power and pursuit of worldly gain—traits far removed from the sacred station of the Imams. The Imams are, by their very nature, leaders; there is no doubt about that. It is the duty of people to embrace their political leadership and devote themselves to their sacred presence. And if the people ask an Imam to establish a just government, the Imam will surely fulfil his duty, having assessed their capacity to do so.
The Imam, the son of our master Ali (peace be upon him), said:
کأنهم لم یسمعوا الله سبحانه [حیث] یقول- تلک الدار الآخره نجعلها للذین لا یریدون علوا فی الأرض و لا فسادا و العاقبه للمتقین بلى و الله لقد سمعوها و وعوها و لکنهم حلیت الدنیا فی أعینهم و راقهم زبرجها أما و الذی فلق الحبه و برأ النسمه لو لا حضور الحاضر و قیام الحجه بوجود الناصر و ما أخذ الله على العلماء ألا یقاروا على کظه ظالم و لا سغب مظلوم لألقیت حبلها على غاربها و لسقیت آخرها بکأس أولها و لألفیتم دنیاکم هذه أزهد عندی من عفطه عنز
Nahj al-Balagha (ed. Subhi Salih), p. 49
Know, O seeker of the sound path and wayfarer on the straight road: By the God who split the seed through His perfect power and created humankind through His consummate wisdom, had those present not been there to pledge allegiance, had the proof not been established against me by the presence of supporters, and had God not taken a covenant from the learned that they must neither tolerate a tyrant’s gluttony nor a wronged person’s hunger, I would surely have cast the reins of the caliphate over its back and given its end the same draught as its beginning. Then you would have found this world of yours, of which you boast, and the faith for which you gamble, to be of less worth to me than a goat’s carcass—or even its sneeze.
Minhaj al-Bara'a fi Sharh Nahj al-Balagha (al-Khu’i), vol. 3, p. 112
#Response1409 Part Two
⏪(To dim the light of guidance in people’s eyes) the enemies of the Light bring up the story of Uraynab, claiming that Yazid wanted to take revenge on Imam Husayn (peace be upon him) because of her, in a romantic rivalry.
This story was invented by the nonsense-writer Ibn Qutayba al-Dinawari, who, out of ignorance and malice, dared to show such disrespect toward the sacred person of Imam Husayn (peace be upon him)!
Earthly passions belong to the blind-hearted. The son of the Eye of God, who bears the title Heart of God, is himself a sacred being and a wellspring of love; love for all creation flows from his blessed soul. A mother’s love for her child, the attraction between husband and wife—all of it is among the rays cast by the sun of divine love, Imam Husayn (peace be upon him), for he is God’s mercy to His creation. How could such a blessed being, from the radiance of whose beautiful countenance the houris were created, and before whom Paradise, with all its beauty and all it contains, is but dust, possibly become enamoured of dust? The whole world and all its people are in love with the dust of his path!
و فتق نور الحسین فخلق منه الجنان و الحور العین و الحسین و الله أجل من الجنان و الحور العین
God cleft the light of Husayn and created Paradise and the houris from it; and, by God, Husayn is more exalted than Paradise and the houris!
The houris are the essence of sublime beauty and every delight combined, created from the light of Husayn’s soul. Anyone who does not know Husayn will be deprived of beauty’s colours and forms and of all delights, for God, the All-Knowing, fashioned beauty and delight with the Husayni pen!
God is in love with Husayn, and Husayn is in love with God!
[إلهی] ما ذا وجد من فقدک و ما الذی فقد من وجدک لقد خاب من رضی دونک بدلا
Imam Husayn (peace be upon him): My God, what has the one who has lost You (and become heedless of You) gained? And what has the one who has found You lost? Truly, wretched is whoever is content with anything other than You!
#Question1409 Peace be upon you. The doubts continue, as do the efforts of the Yazidis of our time to fight Imam Husayn (peace be upon him).
They say:
#Response1409 Part Three
⏪Is it justifiable for people to call themselves the dogs of Imam Husayn علیه السلام and hold ceremonies on that basis?
Acts of this kind may be carried out with different intentions.
First, an enemy may stage them through a covert plot, intending to strike at the Husayni gatherings and, by extension, to carry out a plan to destroy Shiism and turn the world away from the People of the House of Purity and Infallibility علیهم السلام.
Second, they may be done out of ignorance; yet the harm they cause is just as devastating as in the first case.
Third, they may be a low and misguided way of expressing humility and submission before the revered Imams علیهم السلام. Their harm to the school of the Ahl al-Bayt is no less than that caused by the first and second cases.
Their Eminences expect their devotees to be sincere Shi'a. A self-willed devotee is not beloved in their pure and holy presence. A servant should strive to resemble his master, not wound his sacred heart by creating scenes that are base and vile.
The Shi'a and devotees of Their Eminences should adorn themselves with every noble virtue.
Anyone who intends to show humility and submission should know the rules that govern them.
Some of the principles of humility and reverence:
Those who are humble and reverent are devoted to prayer, fasting and noble acts of worship.
البقره : 45 و استعینوا بالصبر و الصلاه و إنها لکبیره إلا على الخاشعین
Seek help through patience and prayer (draw strength through steadfastness, restraint of inward desires, and turning to the Lord); this is indeed a hard thing, except for the humble.
They are devoted to night vigils, the night prayer, intimate supplication and prostration.
الإسراء : 109 و یخرون للأذقان یبکون و یزیدهم خشوعا
They fall down upon their faces, weeping, and this (recitation of these verses) increases their humility.
The heart is the seat of humility and reverence.
الحدید : 16 أ لم یأن للذین آمنوا أن تخشع قلوبهم لذکر الله و ما نزل من الحق و لا یکونوا کالذین أوتوا الکتاب من قبل فطال علیهم الأمد فقست قلوبهم و کثیر منهم فاسقون
Has the time not come for the hearts of the believers to become humble at the remembrance of God and the truth He has sent down, and for them not to be like those who were given the Book before, then, after a long passage of time, whose hearts became hardened? Many of them are transgressors.