From which religious principle is the law's approach to improper hijab (which is a form of norm-breaking) derived? In other words, on what basis are the enforcement of that law and the methods of dealing with offenders (and their scope) determined?
What is the basis for the law’s approach to improper hijab?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Immodest dress in public amounts to disregarding a divine ruling and warrants punishment. Its repetition constitutes a struggle against divine law and carries a doubled penalty. Moreover, the erosion of chastity and of the community's psychological calm calls for a further penalty, since safeguarding public chastity is the duty of the governing authority. Determining and specifying the type of punishment rests with the religious judge.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterObserving hijab is a divine command and law. Anyone who disregards a divine command is certainly liable to punishment. Each transgression of divine law carries a penalty proportionate to its nature. As for violating the hijab ruling in public, no specific punishment appears to have been prescribed in the sacred Sharia. Perhaps this is because, in the time of the Messenger of God (peace be upon him) and the Imams (peace be upon them), people were so committed to observing it that no disciplinary punishment for offenders is mentioned in the historical record. In other words, such violations either did not occur or were very rare.
A person who appears in public without hijab disregards a divine ruling and is therefore liable to punishment. If that person repeatedly fails to observe hijab, this amounts to defiance of divine law and warrants a more severe penalty. Moreover, since this conduct undermines society’s chastity and psychological well-being, a further punishment may be imposed on those who appear without hijab on that account. One of the government’s duties is to preserve social order and tranquillity, as well as public chastity.
Of course, determining the type of punishment and how to deal with the matter is the responsibility of the Islamic judge.
Every government has a duty to safeguard society’s psychological well-being. Those who contribute to society’s psychological illness are undoubtedly offenders and deserve punishment!!!