Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2787 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Is Creational Worship Related to Specific Acts and Rituals of Worship?

Primary reference: See the answer text 28 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2787

Worship means a kind of bowing before the one worshipped—and doing so freely.

Why does God regard placing all creatures within the sphere of creation, in the realm of ontological existence, as a kind of worship?

Does worship have another meaning?

What you said seems, on the face of it, to accord with what those mystics have said, except for the question of the unity of being. (At least, that is how I understood them: they seem to be saying the same thing.)

Unless we interpret these verses as referring to a realm other than this world, such as the primordial realm of the covenant,

and understand that legislated worship began in this world, when human beings were given free will.

But if we place the ontological order in this world, then disbelief no longer exists; there is only certainty and faith.
Eternal dwelling in Hell becomes sheer delight,
and in the ontological order there is no distinction at all between Paradise and Hell, Iblis and the angel, disbeliever and believer.
This is precisely Ibn Arabi’s theory, and on this basis people begin interpreting verses and narrations allegorically...

#Response 2796

If you look again more carefully, you will see that the spirit and substance of what I have said are in sharp conflict with their propositions!

Ontological worship has nothing to do with particular acts and rites of worship. Rather, the very being and essence of creatures is pure worship. In other words, the very creation of beings is a constant, enduring system of worship and servitude; their essence, creation, design, and wondrous formation are the manifestation and expression of worship and servitude. This worship is unceasing and constant; it is never separated from the life of creatures. It is a reality that cannot be invalidated.

Worship in the realm of religious law, however, means carrying out the duties and obligations ordained by the Lawgiver of existence. No act other than these counts as worship. Whether or not one performs acts of worship under religious law has no effect on the ontological order of beings, for that order retains its own distinct place and is unchangeable.

In legislated worship, even the slightest trace of ostentation or insincerity causes a particular act of worship to lose its validity—not to mention worshipping a calf, a stone, a piece of wood, or the self.

In the polytheists’ worship of idols, it is the polytheists’ very essence and existential constitution—their framework and their intricate design—that is oriented toward the worship and adoration of the Lord. Their voluntary acts and conduct, by contrast, have no standing as worship: they constitute shirk, stem from the polytheists’ own ignorance, and will be punished with severe retribution.

In the ontological order, Paradise has been created for reward and Hell for punishment!

Disbelief and faith are matters of human choice in the realm of religious law, and the disbeliever and believer are distinct from one another!

Despite possessing an ontological order, the agent’s very being will be rewarded or punished for its acts under religious law.

A brief look at some verses that may seem to connect religious law with the ontological order:

Maryam: 93
إن کل من فی السماوات و الأرض إلا آتی الرحمن عبدا

“All who are in the heavens and the earth come before the All-Merciful as servants.”

This noble verse establishes an important point: none of God’s creatures can step outside the sphere of servitude to God. It is not the case that all the worship offered by God’s servants—whether by monotheists or polytheists—is, in the ontological order, counted as worship of God. In the presence of the One worshipped, all God’s creatures are His servants, but they occupy different ranks and stations. The fact that God’s creatures are His servants does not mean that all their acts of worship are divine worship.

Al-Inshiqaq: 6
یا أیها الإنسان إنک کادح إلى‏ ربک کدحا فملاقیه

“O human being, you are surely striving toward your Lord with great effort, and you will meet Him.”

The meeting includes both the righteous and the wicked: the righteous attain God’s good pleasure, while the wicked meet His punishment. The following verses explain this point:

فأما من أوتى‏ کتابه بیمینه(7)
فسوف یحاسب حسابا یسیرا(8)
و ینقلب إلى أهله مسرورا(9)
و أما من أوتى‏ کتابه وراء ظهره(10)
فسوف یدعوا ثبورا(11)
و یصلى‏ سعیرا(12)
إنه کان فى أهله مسرورا(13)

“As for the one who is given his record in his right hand, (7)
he will soon be called to account with an easy reckoning, (8)
and will return to his family rejoicing. (9)
But as for the one who is given his record behind his back, (10)
he will soon cry out for destruction, (11)
and enter the blazing Fire. (12)
For he used to rejoice among his family, (13)”

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Creational worship refers to the very essence of creation and the inner nature of created beings, which constitute a fixed and permanent system of worship and servitude, and it has no connection to specific acts and rituals of worship. Legislative worship requires fulfilling divine duties and obligations; hypocrisy or impurity has no validity in it and leads to polytheism and punishment.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

If you look carefully once again, you will find that the spirit and substance of my arguments stand in stark opposition to their propositions!

Ontological worship has nothing to do with particular devotional acts or rites. Rather, the very being and essence of created things constitutes worship. In other words, the very act of bringing beings into existence is a fixed and perpetual system of worship and servitude. Their essence, creation, design, originality, and so on are manifestations of worship and servitude. This worship is ceaseless and constant; it is never separated from the life of created things. It is a reality that cannot be invalidated.

Worship in the realm of revealed law, however, means carrying out the duties and obligations prescribed by the Lawgiver of existence. No act other than this counts as worship. Whether or not beings engage in worship under the revealed law has no effect on their ontological state, since that state remains in its own proper place, unchanged.

In worship under the revealed law, even the slightest trace of ostentation or insincerity in a specific act of devotion strips it of its standing as worship—let alone the worship of a calf, a stone, a piece of wood, or the self.

In the polytheists’ worship of idols, it is their very essence and existential nature, their framework and the design of their being, that constitutes worship of the Lord—not their voluntary acts and conduct, which have no standing as worship, constitute associating partners with God, and arise from the polytheists’ own ignorance. They will be severely punished for them.

In the realm of creation, Paradise was brought into being as reward, and Hell as punishment.

Disbelief and faith are matters of human choice in the realm of revealed law; the unbeliever and the believer are distinct from one another.

In the realm of revealed law, an agent will be rewarded or punished for their acts under that law, despite possessing an ontological order of their own.

A brief look at some verses that may seem to link revealed law with creation

Maryam 93: إن کل من فی السماوات و الأرض إلا آتی الرحمن عبدا

All who are in the heavens and the earth will come before the Most Merciful in humble servitude.

This noble verse establishes an important point: none of God’s creatures can step outside the sphere of servitude to Him. This does not mean that all the worship performed by God’s servants—whether monotheistic or polytheistic—is, in the ontological order, counted as worship of God. In the presence of the One who is worshipped, all of God’s creatures are His servants, though they occupy different ranks and stations. The fact that God’s creatures are His servants does not mean that all their acts of worship are worship of God.

Al-Inshiqaq 6: یا أیها الإنسان إنک کادح إلى‏ ربک کدحا فملاقیه

O human being, you are surely striving toward your Lord with strenuous effort, and you will meet Him.

This meeting encompasses both the righteous and the wicked: the righteous attain God’s good pleasure, while the wicked meet His punishment. The verses that follow this noble verse explain the point:

فأما من أوتى‏ کتابه بیمینه(7)
فسوف یحاسب حسابا یسیرا(8)
و ینقلب إلى أهله مسرورا(9)
و أما من أوتى‏ کتابه وراء ظهره(10)
فسوف یدعوا ثبورا(11)
و یصلى‏ سعیرا(12)
إنه کان فى أهله مسرورا(13)

As for the one who is given his record in his right hand, (7)
he will soon be given an easy reckoning, (8)
and return to his family rejoicing. (9)
But as for the one who is given his record from behind his back, (10)
he will soon cry out for destruction, (11)
and burn in a blazing fire, (12)
for he was always rejoicing among his family. (13)

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022