The standard is not simply prayer, fasting, the Qur’an and so on. If it were, ISIS members pray too—often in congregation. They call upon God in their prayers, so why does God not guide them? They read the Qur’an and act on their interpretations of its verses; they fast as well. What is it about the remembrance of God in our prayers and our fasting that will make God truly accept us? They, too, say “Allāhu akbar” with that intention and remember God, yet look at what they do in practice…
How can we know whether our prayers, intentions and deeds are sound, and whether we have lost our way…?
We often hear people say that Islam is what ISIS practises. What kind of religion is this? Or they ask: “What kind of religion is it where both the killer and the victim say ‘Allāhu akbar’, and both believe they will be martyrs and go to Paradise—yet they worship the same God and follow the same Prophet, and still kill one another like this…?!”
My dear teacher, my heart aches. I weep for pure Muhammadan Islam… I am beginning to understand why Ali, peace be upon him, suffered so much at the hands of the Kharijites…
What has become of us? Esteemed teacher, what answer can we give them?
Thank you very much.