Hello! There’s something I’ve been wondering about for a while.
What’s the difference between a talisman like this and reliable supplications?
I saw somewhere that all these things listed under the name of occult sciences are talismans, even if they contain prayers.
But some of the supplications here also include letters whose meaning isn’t clear, and those were in them too.
How can we tell what’s a talisman and what’s a reliable supplication?
For example, is Abu Dujana’s hirz a talisman or a reliable supplication?
What Is the Difference Between a Talisman and a Reliable Supplication?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Reliable supplications are those transmitted from the Infallibles (AS), or those that bear the mark of devotion to the Ahl al-Bayt. Talismans often contain unfamiliar words, making them difficult to distinguish from reliable supplications. Abu Dujana’s hirz is also a transmitted supplication, but its chain of transmission is weak. It seems to have been intended for personal use and is not suitable for general use.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterReported supplications—those transmitted from the sacred presence of the revered figures, and those that bear the fragrance of devotion to the Ahl al-Bayt—are worthy of consideration!
The chain of transmission for this supplication is weak!
It seems that, if authentic, this supplication was personal rather than intended for general use, and was specific to Abu Dujana!
Anyone who wishes to use it should treat it as one would a medicine.
For warding off specific difficulties, there are transmitted and reliable supplications that one can make use of.
“Talism” is an unusual word and does not appear to be Arabic! Supplication has its own proper place.
The supplication known as the supplication of Abu Dujana:
حرز أبی دجانه مروی عن النبی ص و هو
هذا کتاب محمد رسول الله رب العالمین إلى من طرق الدار من العمار و الزوار إلا طارقا یطرق بخیر أما بعد فإن لنا و لکم فی الحق سعه فإن تک عاشقا مولعا أو فاجرا مقتحما فهذا کتاب الله ینطق علینا و علیکم بالحق إنا کنا نستنسخ ما کنتم تعملون و رسلنا یکتبون ما تمکرون اترکوا صاحب کتابی هذا و انطلقوا إلى عبده الأصنام و إلى من یزعم أن مع الله إلها آخر لا إله إلا هو کل شیء هالک إلا وجهه له الحکم و إلیه ترجعون حم لا ینصرون حم عسق تفرقت أعداء الله و بلغت حجه الله و لا حول و لا قوه إلا بالله [العلی العظیم] فسیکفیکهم الله و هو السمیع العلیم.
المصباح للکفعمی (جنه الأمان الواقیه)، ص: 229