Could you please explain the difference between divine infallibility and the infallibility of prophets and saints?
What Is the Difference Between Divine Infallibility and the Infallibility of Prophets and Saints?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
God is not described as infallible; rather, He is transcendent above all imperfection, and He is the Protector. The Lord is the source of a created being’s infallibility, and prophets and saints are tested as they attain higher degrees. The infallibility of Muhammad and the Family of Muhammad (PBUH) is beyond and encompasses all infallibility, and cannot be compared with that of any prophet.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterGod, the Lord of all the worlds, is not described as infallible. Rather, it is more fitting to describe Him as transcendent in His holiness, in keeping with the Quranic way of speaking. Infallibility is something the Lord bestows upon His creatures; He is the One who protects, not One who possesses infallibility. He is exalted above having infallibility in order to be free of error. (سبحان ربک رب العزه عما یصفون )
یا عاصم
یا عاصم قلوب النبیین
، و یا عاصم النبیین
یا عاصم من استعصمه
Muhammad and the Family of Muhammad, peace be upon them, possess a station beyond infallibility and embody its fullest perfection! Their infallibility, in light of the Verse of Purification, is incomparable to that of any prophet! They possess the purest diamond of infallibility!
Yet the other great prophets, though infallible in the sphere of their mission, were tested through many trials as they attained the highest degrees.