What is the power of choice by which a free agent prefers one action over another—and how does it choose between good and evil?⁉
What Is the Power of Choice, and How Does It Choose Between Good and Evil?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Choice is described not in terms of power or capacity, but as the possibility of choosing. It ranks above intellect and ignorance, because intellect became beloved of God through a good choice, while ignorance became accursed through a bad one. To the same extent that an agent endowed with free choice can prefer good to evil, they can also prefer evil to good.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterFree choice cannot be described in terms of power or capacity, or by any other expression, whatever it may be. It is what makes a being capable of choosing. Among the other faculties, free choice ranks higher and is more ancient, for before the hosts of reason and ignorance came into being, the noble Intellect became beloved of God through its good choice, while Ignorance became accursed by God through its bad choice.
Just as a free agent has the capacity to prefer good to evil, so too, in equal measure, it has the capacity to prefer evil to good.
If one direction could be preferred over the others more readily, free choice would lose its essential character. So, given free choice, there is nothing surprising about its possessor inclining in one direction and choosing one side.