What is the renewal of similars? Is it the same as substantial motion, or is there a difference?
What Is the Renewal of Similars, and How Does It Differ from Substantial Motion?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The renewal of similars (tajaddud al-amthāl) is a theological, mystical, and philosophical concept describing the passing away of something and the emergence of something like it. It applies to all created things, both material and immaterial. Mulla Sadra’s original theory of substantial motion, by contrast, applies only to the material realm. The two theories are related, but they are not the same.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe renewal of similitudes is a theological, mystical, and philosophical term referring to the passing away of something and the coming into being of something like it.
Drawing on Quranic expressions, some mystics refer to this mystical doctrine by terms such as the renewal of similitudes, the transformation of similitudes, and new creation.
The renewal of similitudes is not the same as substantial motion. It is a broader concept, applying equally to all created things—material and immaterial, substances and accidents alike—and holding them all to be subject to renewal and transformation. Mulla Sadra’s original theory of substantial motion, by contrast, is confined to the material realm: it applies primarily to material substances and, derivatively, to their accidents.
Yet the two theories—the renewal of similitudes and substantial motion—are related and share important features.
According to some mystics, the things of the universe are in a state of perpetual creation. In their view, no created thing is self-subsistent at any moment. It does not need to be created only once; this need is renewed from moment to moment, and God is creating at every instant. Beings are manifestations of the Divine Names, and the Divine Names are perpetually active. The Name that brings things into being is ceaselessly bringing them into being, while the Name that annihilates is ceaselessly annihilating them. In Rumi’s view, the universe is renewed moment by moment; its stability and permanence are merely an illusion born of our heedlessness.
The discussion, analysis, and critique of the renewal of similitudes call for more time! ان شاء, at a suitable opportunity, we will be granted the chance to take it up.