In discussions of the world’s origination and eternity, what do temporal origination and essential origination mean? What was Mulla Sadra’s view, and what is atemporal origination (huduth dahri), which seems complicated to me? Ultimately, what is the truth of the matter?
What Is the Truth About the World’s Origination and Eternity?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The truth about the world’s origination and eternity is that the universe is originated: the Creator has brought it into existence. The argument from motion shows that every motion has a beginning, and that anything with a beginning is originated. A report from Imam al-Baqir (AS) likewise states that the first thing created was water, which God created not from anything that had existed before it. This means that the universe was not preceded by nonexistence; rather, the Creator brought it into existence.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterJabir al-Ju‘fi relates that a man from among the scholars of Syria came to Imam Muhammad al-Baqir (AS) and said, “I have come to ask you about a question. I have not found anyone who could explain it to me and make it clear. I asked three different groups of people, and each group gave me an answer different from the others.” Imam al-Baqir (AS) said, “What is the question?” He replied, “I ask you: what was the first thing God, Mighty and Majestic, created among His creatures?” Some of those foolish people I asked said “power”; others said “knowledge”; and still others said “spirit.”
Imam al-Baqir (AS) said, “They have said nothing. What they have said is empty and without substance. I will tell you: God—exalted is His mention—was, and there was nothing apart from Him. He was mighty, and there was no might, for He existed before His might. This is the meaning of His words:
سبحان ربک رب العزه عما یصفون
That is: I declare your Lord, the Lord of might and power, exalted above what they ascribe to Him.
“He was the Creator, and there was no created thing. The first thing He created among His creatures was that from which all things come: water.”
The questioner said, “Did God create that thing from something, or from nothing—that is, not from anything?”
He replied, “He created it not from anything that had existed before it. Had He created it from something, there would never have been any end to it; and then God would always have existed with something alongside Him. But God existed, and there was nothing alongside Him. He created that from which all things come: water.”
*Secrets of Divine Unity / Translation of al-Tawhid by al-Saduq*, p. 53
All essences and attributes in this universe—and, consequently, the universe itself—are originated: they did not exist, and the Creator brought them into existence!
**Proof by contradiction:** If we suppose that the universe, or one of the beings within it, was eternal—that is, had never been preceded by nonexistence—the result would be that both the Creator and this being were eternal. But if a being is eternal, creation has no meaning for it, since something must be either Creator or created. If it is not created, then it must be the Creator. Two creators in one place would deprive both of eternity, everlastingness, and infinity; in other words, under these conditions, both would be created beings! The conclusion is that the universe is originated, and the Creator brought it into existence!
**The argument from motion:** Everything in this universe is in motion, undergoing change and transformation. Every motion has a beginning, a starting point; in effect, it has a zero. Moreover, the continuance of that motion depends on the continued will of the one who sets it in motion. If that will were to change from motion to stillness, beings would cease to move and would perish. Thus every motion has a beginning and an end, and anything that has a beginning is originated.
One longstanding objection to the argument from motion may be raised: how does a beginning itself begin? Put another way, how can something that did not exist have a beginning? And, put yet another way, how can its initial unit, the first constituent, exist—and what could its time be?
The answer is that what we understand by time or by a beginning is, in fact, only a concept of time, a concept of an origin or beginning—not its reality. This is what leaves us confused. If we examine the question of time closely, we find that, in reality, neither past nor present nor future can have an external existence in the sense we understand by time. Yet because we truly sense their external existence, this undeniable reality proves that our understanding of time, space, and beings is limited, and our knowledge is scant.
**The transmitted proof:**
عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: خلق الله المشیئه بنفسها ثم خلق الأشیاء بالمشیئه.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج1، ص: 110
God created will itself, then created things through His will!
عن جابر الجعفی قال: جاء رجل من علماء أهل الشام إلى أبی جعفر ع فقال جئت أسألک عن مسأله لم أجد أحدا یفسرها لی و قد سألت ثلاثه أصناف من الناس فقال کل صنف غیر ما قال الآخر فقال أبو جعفر ع و ما ذلک فقال أسألک ما أول ما خلق الله عز و جل من خلقه سلامفإن بعض من سألته قال القدره و قال بعضهم العلم و قال بعضهم الروح فقال أبو جعفر ع ما قالوا شیئا أخبرک أن الله علا ذکره کان و لا شیء غیره و کان عزیزا و لا عز لأنه کان قبل عزه و ذلک قوله- سبحان ربک رب العزه عما یصفون «2» و کان خالقا و لا مخلوق «3» فأول شیء خلقه من خلقه الشیء الذی جمیع الأشیاء منه و هو الماء «4» فقال السائل فالشیء خلقه من شیء أو من لا شیء فقال خلق الشیء لا من شیء کان قبله و لو خلق الشیء من شیء إذا لم یکن له انقطاع أبدا و لم یزل الله إذا و معه شیء «5» و لکن کان الله و لا شیء معه فخلق الشیء الذی جمیع الأشیاء منه و هو الماء.
التوحید (للصدوق)، ص: 66