Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2322 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

What Qualities Must Someone Possess to Judge Others, and Is It Permissible to Do So?

Primary reference: See the answer text 32 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Judging others—especially eminent scholars—requires qualities such as thorough knowledge, integrity, and expert familiarity with the subject being judged. A person’s character alone is not enough to establish the validity of their words; those words must be measured against the standard of the Two Weighty Things—the Qur’an and the Prophet’s family—to guard against intellectual deviation and personal bias.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

The subject of judgment and its rules calls for extensive discussion and ample time. The question at hand, however, concerns assessing a scholar and passing judgment on his circumstances. Although criticism of scholars is a particular kind of judgment, the foundation of judgment is justice. Justice cannot be attained unless the judge (or critic) is fully qualified in knowledge—that is, unless the judge has sufficient scholarly and technical expertise in the subject on which he is passing judgment.

Judging a judge is, of course, a higher-order judgment (“criticizing a critic is a higher-order critique”), since in this case the judge must be superior to the first judge, or at least his equal.

Just as a judge must possess justice and knowledge, an endorsement of scholars must also be grounded in knowledge, not offered blindly or on the basis of personal feelings. No one’s personal standing can, by itself, be a sufficient basis for endorsing their words, ideas, or theories.

An-Nisa, 4:58: إن الله یأمرکم أن تؤدوا الأمانات إلى‏ أهلها و إذا حکمتم بین الناس أن تحکموا بالعدل إن الله نعما یعظکم به إن الله کان سمیعا بصیرا

God commands you to return trusts to those entitled to them, and when you judge between people, to judge fairly. How excellent is the counsel God gives you! God is All-Hearing, All-Seeing.

Al-Ma’ida, 5:49: و أن احکم بینهم بما أنزل الله و لا تتبع أهواءهم و احذرهم أن یفتنوک عن بعض ما أنزل الله إلیک فإن تولوا فاعلم أنما یرید الله أن یصیبهم ببعض ذنوبهم و إن کثیرا من الناس لفاسقون

Judge between them according to what God has revealed, and do not follow their desires. Beware lest they turn you away from some of what God has revealed to you. If they turn away, know that God intends to punish them for some of their sins. Indeed, many people are defiantly disobedient.

#Follow-up_to_Question_2322

Greetings and warm regards to our esteemed teacher and respected companions,

I would like to offer you my special thanks for answering my questions. من لم یشکر المخلوق لم یشکر الخالق .

For quite some time, many different people have been discussing mysticism, both online and in person. They hold titles such as Allama, religious expert, Ayatollah, and Hujjat al-Islam, among others. Now that we have found you, when we encounter the mystical teachings put forward by these individuals, should we take your statements as our standard, or theirs? I noticed above that you have a particular perspective on some scholars. I would be grateful for your guidance.

…The Quran has a teacher, and the teachers of the Quran are the Ahl al-Bayt علیهم السلام. We, however, have no access to the Ahl al-Bayt. What, then, are we to do? Did Shurayh the Judge not read the Quran? Did he not pray? Did he not know that Imam Husayn صلوات الله علیه was the son of the Messenger of God صلی الله علیه و آله و سلم?

Besides, those who follow these scholars share your view and believe that their words contain nothing beyond the Quran and hadiths…

…

The point now is that every scholar and mystic invokes the Quran and the words of the Ahl al-Bayt.

For example (without intending to compare them), how am I supposed to tell whether our esteemed teacher, Mr. Saei, is right, or Allama Hasan-Zadeh Amoli? Or perhaps both distinguished gentlemen are right, and it is our level of understanding that is low.

This is a problem for most young people like me.

#Response_to_Follow-up_to_Question_2322

The doctrine of tawhid is the central pillar of a person’s faith, and one must attain certainty in it without relying on imitation. The One and Only Creator has planted the very heart of belief in His oneness within us and made us naturally disposed to it; by our innate nature, we believe in it. This book and register of tawhid, then, serves as a credential and confirmation for anyone who makes a claim—whether to prophethood, to wilayah, or to the truth.

To benefit from the innate nature entrusted to us, we must put its unchanging self-evident truths into practice and firmly establish them. The human intellect is the interpreter of the book of our innate nature. To read it, we must be equipped with the seventy-five troops of reason, so that we can make this entire book clear and put it into practice in all aspects of our lives. The seventy-five troops of reason are forces within the human heart whose truth we accept without any intermediary. Once we allow them to operate within the heart, the power to distinguish and discern will readily take shape within us.

Now that we have laid this foundation, the fragrance of the Two Weighty Things, discernible in the beliefs and teachings of a righteous person, will serve as a reliable guide to quickly recognizing the person we seek.

Those who have grown weary of wandering through scattered lanes are surely not closely attached to the Two Weighty Things!

Shurayh the judge, however, though he recited the Qur’an, had not accepted that the Ahl al-Bayt should accompany it. The Qur’an without the Ahl al-Bayt is the Qur’an raised on spears, scraps of paper—in a word, a Qur’an without the Qur’an.

Among those who claim wilayah, accompanying the Qur’an and holding fast to both together are necessary conditions; acting upon them and following them are sufficient conditions for the religious soundness of the person we seek.

قال الصادق ع الخشیه میراث العلم و میزانه و العلم شعاع المعرفه و قلب الإیمان و من حرم الخشیه لا یکون عالما و إن شق الشعر بمتشابهات العلم قال الله تعالى إنما یخشى الله من عباده العلماء و آفه العلماء ثمانیه الطمع و البخل و الریاء و العصبیه و حب المدح و الخوض فیما لم یصلوا إلى حقیقته و التکلف فی تزیین الکلام بزوائد الألفاظ و قله الحیاء من الله و الافتخار و ترک العمل بما علموا قال عیسى ع أشقى الناس من هو معروف‏ بعلمه مجهول بعمله و قال النبی ص لا تجلسوا عند کل داع مدع یدعوکم من الیقین إلى الشک و من الإخلاص إلى الریاء و من التواضع إلى الکبر و من النصیحه إلى العداوه و من الزهد إلى الرغبه و تقربوا إلى عالم یدعوکم إلى التواضع من الکبر و من الریاء إلى الإخلاص و من الشک إلى الیقین و من الرغبه إلى الزهد و من العداوه إلى النصیحه و لا یصلح لموعظه الخلق إلا من جاوز هذه الآفات بصدقه و أشرف على عیوب الکلام و عرف الصحیح من السقیم و علل الخواطر و فتن النفس و الهوى قال علی ع کن کالطبیب الرفیق الشفیق الذی یضع الدواء بحیث ینفع فی الخبر سألوا عیسى ابن مریم ع یا روح الله مع من نجالس قال ع من یذکرکم الله رؤیته و یزید فی علمکم منطقه و یرغبکم فی الآخره عمله‏
مصباح الشریعه، ص: 22

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022