If a man is caught between his wife and his parents and cannot make peace between them, what is his duty? Can he leave them all to fend for themselves? Or should he support his wife when his parents mistreat her? (Especially since she has no one in that family to stand up for her.)
What should a man do if he is caught between his wife and his parents?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Respecting one’s parents does not mean staying silent when they act unjustly, and a man should not leave his wife to face their mistreatment alone. His duty is to prevent his parents from wronging his wife and to uphold everyone’s rights, while treating his parents respectfully and acting with wisdom. Enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong should be done with even greater resolve when it concerns those close to us.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterPermission to commit injustice or sin has never been granted to anyone, under any circumstances or for anyone’s sake—not even in the name of honoring one’s parents!
Respect for parents does not mean remaining silent in the face of their wrongdoing or, God forbid, taking their side. In fact, that would be among the most reprehensible forms of respect. The duty to enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong must not be waived when it comes to one’s relatives; if anything, it should be carried out with even greater resolve. One must fulfill this duty while still showing due respect.
الشعراء : 214 و أنذر عشیرتک الأقربین
And warn your closest relatives!
النساء : 135 یا أیها الذین آمنوا کونوا قوامین بالقسط شهداء لله و لو على أنفسکم أو الوالدین و الأقربین إن یکن غنیا أو فقیرا فالله أولى بهما فلا تتبعوا الهوى أن تعدلوا و إن تلووا أو تعرضوا فإن الله کان بما تعملون خبیرا
O you who believe! Stand firmly for justice and bear witness for God, even if it is against yourselves, your parents, or your close relatives. Whether they are rich or poor, God has a greater claim to their welfare. So do not follow your desires, lest you depart from justice. And if you distort the truth or turn away from it, God is fully aware of what you do.
In the situation described, if the parents’ material and spiritual needs can be met without the person in question, and living near them—whether intentionally or not—leads to hardship and injustice, then the duty is to reduce and prevent any transgression by the parents, through tactful management and sound judgment.