How and under what circumstances does seeking help from the Infallibles amount to shirk?
When does seeking help from the Infallibles amount to shirk?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Seeking help from the Infallibles is considered shirk when a person regards them as independent of God or as His equals. If one seeks their help while believing in the oneness and lordship of God Almighty, and in the conviction that they are God’s sincere servants, it is permissible and blessed. Any help from anyone or anything comes only through God’s help.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterAl-Muʿīn, the Helper, is one of the Divine Names. Through this beautiful Name, Allah helps all creation. The Infallible Ones, peace be upon them, are among the Divine Names of Beauty; through His finest creatures, God grants help to creation. The Creator brings all these matters to pass.
The origin and end of every phenomenon lead back to God.
In their very existence, and likewise in their survival, continuity, movement, and everything else, all beings depend on God. All these things come to pass through Him and with His help.
Every movement that takes place in this world, whether great or small—from a breeze stirring to a storm, from the movement of planets and galaxies to that of an atom or an electron—comes about with God’s help. Whoever denies this truth is undoubtedly an unbeliever.
From walking and leaping to blinking and moving a finger, breathing and thinking—all of these take place with God’s help. There is no doubt about it.
In many matters that the Creator has made dependent on causes, every cause undoubtedly depends on Him in its capacity to cause. It is God’s help that gives a cause its efficacy and makes it effective.
Although, in ordinary circumstances, no one cries out to God while walking, saying, “God, help me breathe; God, help me walk; God, help me blink,” and so on, we do all these things with God’s help. Believing this truth is enough; there is no need to say it aloud, though expressing it is beautiful.
In the repeated, customary, everyday affairs of life, people seek help from one another without regarding this as worship. Someone who gets into a car, uses a lever or a crane, hires a worker, puts on shoes, eats food, and so on is seeking assistance in every one of these acts, even if not a word is spoken. No sound-minded person would accuse such people of polytheism for relying on means.
In this worldly life, we turn to specialists to address many important needs. For example, when someone falls ill, they do not go to a grocer but consult a doctor and seek treatment that way. Or, when they have a technical problem, they turn to the appropriate engineer to resolve it, and so on. In all these consultations and requests, no one takes anyone else as their deity; they make use of the means God has provided to meet their needs. Anyone who regards those who meet their needs—that is, the means themselves—as independent is an unbeliever. For example, if someone regards the effects of a medicinal plant that relieves pain, a medical prescription that works, or an engineer who sets up a factory as independent of their true source, the Essence of God Most High, they are an unbeliever. Without a doubt.
Although God, the Great and Exalted, has not entrusted every matter to means, anything brought about through means comes about solely through God’s help. More precisely, every help we receive from anyone is, in truth, help granted by God. Every appeal for assistance, whether made to someone or something, helps us and all other beings only through God’s help. والسلام!
Now consider the role of the Infallible Ones, peace be upon them, in the existence of this world. Their role is like that of light, water, and bread. They are more expert than any specialist; indeed, they are not merely masters of many arts but masters of every art. By the grace of the Lord, their power surpasses atomic energy; their attention and regard are more effective than any herb or medicine. The outpouring of divine mercy through them is more wholesome than any food or drink, more nourishing and quenching. The light of their sacred existence shines brighter than any sun, illuminating the lands of our bodies and souls, and the world itself, in the brightest way.
If we seek the help of the Infallible Ones, peace be upon them, with complete soundness of heart—that is, with faith in the oneness of God Most High, belief in His absolute Lordship, faith in the Prophethood and Imamate of the Infallible Ones, and conviction that they are God’s true and truthful servants—then seeking their help, of course, along the Straight Path, is right and blessed.
The Straight Path of seeking help is the path on which the Divine Essence is compared with no phenomenon whatsoever; everything other than Him, including the Infallible Ones, peace be upon them, is distinct from Him.
The Infallibles, peace be upon them, are God’s truthful servants and creatures. In certain matters, our requests for their help must be confined, within the bounds of monotheistic reason, to matters that we know God, the All-Powerful, has permitted them to bring about.
If someone lacks a sound heart, does not believe in and know the oneness of God, and has an incomplete faith in Prophethood and Imamate, then all such seeking of help and thought will be mixed with polytheism.
Without the foundation of monotheistic belief, even blinking would be an act of polytheism. In other words, if we believe that the power to blink comes from ourselves, then the act of blinking would be an act of polytheism.