Excuse me, teacher. In our correspondence and everyday speech, we use expressions such as these. Which of them are acceptable according to the Thaqalayn? Please guide me. For example: Ya Allah, Ya Ali, Ya Naqi, Ya Mahdi. Please remember me in your prayers.
Which of the calls “Ya Allah,” “Ya Ali,” “Ya Naqi,” and “Ya Mahdi” is accepted by the Thaqalayn?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Calling upon the Infallibles (for example, saying “Ya Ali,” “Ya Naqi,” or “Ya Mahdi”) is acceptable in the light of the Thaqalayn so long as they are not given a divine status and such calls do not lead to forgetting God or weakening the principles of monotheism. Repeating these invocations should not replace saying “Ya Allah”; rather, they should be offered with sincere intent and in a way that strengthens belief in God’s oneness. Remembering the Infallibles in the context of servitude to God and remembrance of Him has value.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe sacred presence of the revered figures is a tonic for remembrance of God and strengthens the spirit of worship and servitude.
Every call has a response. In other words, when we call upon someone, we have an aim in mind; this is what is called the response to the call, and it is sometimes implicit.
When we say «یا الله», we invoke God in His divinity and lordship. This may be no more than an acknowledgment of His reality and remembrance of Him, or it may be accompanied by requests.
When we say «یا محمد» or «یا علی», and so on, we must be clear about our purpose and intention. If we address the revered figures with the same intention we have when saying «یا الله», we have undoubtedly taken a step toward polytheism.
Of course, the recommended invocation used in times of calamity and distress is not the subject of our discussion.
Even if «یا محمد» or «یا علی», and so on, is not uttered with the intention of invoking lordship, if repeating it leads others to think that we are saying it from a position of lordship, then our invocation is still problematic.
If repeating these invocations becomes a substitute for saying «یا الله», the practice is no different from an act of polytheism.
If repeating such invocations causes us to forget the remembrance of God, then the person repeating them has become an instrument of forgetfulness, drawing people away from the remembrance of God.
If such invocations are used as a form of tawassul to provoke and inflame an opposing group, they are still reprehensible. For this act becomes a barrier to accepting the truth, erected by the speaker so that the other party will have no inclination to accept it. Uttered with this intention, such an invocation amounts to spiritual torment for the other party and is incompatible with sincerity.
There are countless ways to express love and affection for the revered figures, so we have no need to resort to this approach.
The sacred presence of the revered figures is meant to strengthen the foundations of monotheism. Anyone who persists in this kind of invocation is, in effect, using these invocations in the name of the revered figures to weaken the institutions of monotheism.
Without doubt, the revered figures would welcome the repetition of the majestic invocations of God in our greetings and encounters—as words of presence, greeting, farewell and affirmation—for their prayers, addresses and speech are permeated with this practice.
Certainly, if we use the majestic names of God when we meet them, the revered figures will not take offence.
None of the Imams taught their followers this form of tawassul, nor did they themselves resort to it to meet their own needs. Imam Hasan, Imam Husayn, Imam Sajjad and the others, peace be upon them, for example, did not pray using the form «یا محمد ....». If accounts of such prayers are found, they have their own particular subtleties, which must be given careful attention.
Remembering the revered figures in their capacity as servants of God has a special grace and beauty, and is as valuable and worthy as remembrance of God, for their very being is a reminder that calls God to mind—but this must be done with knowledge and spiritual insight.
The remembrance of the revered figures should awaken in our hearts the spirit of remembering and worshipping God and of serving Him; otherwise, we have lost our way.
A gift from this discussion
قال رسول الله ص ذکر الله عز و جل عباده و ذکری عباده و ذکر علی عباده و ذکر الأئمه من ولده عباده
الإختصاص، النص، ص: 224