Which part of this analysis is wrong? If we say that the attributes are not identical with the Essence, we are left with two possibilities. The first is that the divine attributes are parts of the Essence. This is false, since it would mean that the Essence is composite, which is impossible. The second is that the divine attributes are separate from the Essence. In that case, they would either be necessary existents, which would entail the existence of multiple gods and is impossible, or possible existents, which is also false, because it would mean that creatures possess a perfection that God lacks.
Which Part of the Analysis of the Divine Attributes Is Wrong?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The analysis in the question argues that the attributes are identical with the Essence, whereas the words of Imam Ali (peace be upon him), «و کمال الإخلاص له نفی الصفات», emphasize that attributes must be denied of the Essence. God transcends every attribute and perfection. Knowing the attributes is not the same as knowing the Essence, because all knowledge entails comprehension, and God’s Essence cannot be comprehended.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe discussion here concerns establishing that the attributes are identical with the Essence. By contrast, the words of our master, Imam ʿAlī (peace be upon him)—و کمال الإخلاص له نفی الصفات عنه—speak of negating attributes from the Essence. In reality, they affirm this truth:
God transcends and surpasses every attribute, every quality, and every perfection, whether known or unknown. His servants have no way to enter into His incomparable Essence!
When discussing human attributes, we have a partial understanding of them. This knowledge of the attributes shows that the Lord is other than them, for His Essence cannot be known or apprehended. If we were to hold that the attributes of the Real are identical with His Essence, then knowing the attributes would amount to knowing the Essence.
In the case of the Exalted Creator, attributes such as power and names such as the Powerful are one and the same; yet He is beyond power and beyond every perfection and excellence. That is, when applied to the Exalted Creator, an attribute is another name for His unique Essence. Every attribute of perfection is a name and a sign of His one Being, and is regarded as one of His signs.