Whom did Lady Umm Kulthum (AS), daughter of the Commander of the Faithful, Ali ibn Abi Talib (AS), marry? And does this have any particular significance?
Whom Did Lady Umm Kulthum, Daughter of the Commander of the Faithful, Marry?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The Umm Kulthum who married Umar was Abu Bakr’s daughter and Imam Ali’s stepdaughter (raised in his household), not his daughter. Umm Kulthum, the daughter of Lady Fatima (SA), was present at Karbala and, alongside her sisters, cared for Imam Husayn’s children. This in itself is evidence against her having married Umar.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterNo daughter of Mawla Ali عليه السلام was married to Umar! Umm Kulthum, who married Umar, was Abu Bakr’s daughter and was regarded as Mawla Ali’s stepdaughter, having been raised in his household.
**A clarification**
Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr was regarded as Ali ibn Abi Talib’s stepson, and Umm Kulthum, daughter of Abu Bakr, was regarded as Ali ibn Abi Talib’s stepdaughter عليه السلام.
**A contemporary Shia view**
Marashi Najafi, a Shia religious authority, writes on this subject: “Umm Kulthum, who married Umar, was Ali’s stepdaughter عليه السلام, the daughter of Asma bint Umays and Abu Bakr. She was a child, and after Abu Bakr’s death, when Asma married Ali, she came to Ali’s home عليه السلام, grew up there, and married Umar. Everywhere, she was called Umm Kulthum daughter of Ali. She and her son Zayd ibn Umar died during the time of Hasan ibn Ali. Hasan ibn Ali performed the funeral prayer for her and her son together in a single prayer, and this became evidence that it is permissible to perform one funeral prayer for two deceased people. Umm Kulthum, the daughter of Fatima, was in Karbala with her sister Zaynab, and on the night of the eleventh she watched over Imam Husayn’s children until morning. This, too, is evidence against her having married Umar: if she had been Umar’s wife and had a child, this would have been mentioned in accounts of the events at Karbala and during the captivity in Kufa and Syria. They would surely have shown her respect.”
Some Shia writers maintain that Umm Kulthum’s marriage to Umar took place after Ali had repeatedly refused and offered various excuses, and after Umar made various threats; it was arranged through the mediation of Aqil and Abbas, without Ali’s wholehearted consent. They believe that Umar was killed a short time later and Ali brought his daughter back to his home.
All the questions have been raised in the Telegram group “Cave of Questions, Ruby of Answers,” and the answers are from Master Ali Saei.