A follow-up.
Someone might raise a doubt: if the attack was sudden, then how were Imam Ali's (AS) companions who were in the house charged with silence? And why were they present in the house at all?
And if the Imam had instructed his companions to remain silent, then by prior analogy he should also have invited his wife to remain silent!!!
Why Did Imam Ali’s (AS) Companions Remain Silent During the Attack on His House?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Imam Ali's (AS) companions were charged with patience and refraining from retaliation, not with refraining from defense. The cowardly and surprise assault of the attackers deprived the Imam (AS) of the opportunity to defend. The avoidance of retaliation after the event was for the sake of the interests of the noble religion of Islam, and what is meant by silence is the absence of an uprising to seize power, not the absence of defense.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe Imam was commanded to remain patient and not seek revenge, but he was not commanded to refrain from defending himself. His few companions and the overwhelming, surprise attack by the vile people of his time left him no opportunity to defend himself.
Historical accounts indicate that the cowardly attack came without warning, and that the Imam did all he could to defend himself. He refrained from seeking revenge after the attack for the sake of the interests of the noble religion of Islam.
Being commanded to remain silent did not mean that he was forbidden to defend himself. It meant that he was not to seek revenge, rise up, or wage war in order to gain the government.
فأضرم علیهم بیتهم النار فانطلق قنفذ الملعون فاقتحم هو و أصحابه بغیر إذن و ثار علی ع إلى سیفه فسبقوه إلیه [و کاثروه] و هم کثیرون فتناول بعضهم سیوفهم فکاثروه [و ضبطوه] «63»
Qunfudh, may he be accursed, came with his companions and stormed the house without permission. ʿAli, peace be upon him, reached for his sword, but they got to it before he did and, being so numerous, overwhelmed him.
Some of them took up their swords, attacked him, and seized him.