Hello, why did Imam Husayn (AS) fight during a sacred month?
Why Did Imam Husayn (AS) Fight During a Sacred Month?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Imam Husayn (AS) did not initiate a fight during a sacred month; rather, war was forced upon him. He tried to prevent bloodshed and was even willing to return, but Yazid insisted that he pledge allegiance. Divine permission to fight during a sacred month was granted when the enemy violated its sanctity.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterImam Husayn (peace be upon him) was striving to prevent war!
کتب إلی أهل مصرکم هذا أن اقدم فأما إذ کرهتمونی فأنا أنصرف عنکم
Al-Irshad fi Ma'rifat Hujaj Allah 'ala al-'Ibad, vol. 2, p. 85
Imam Husayn (peace be upon him), addressing a messenger from Umar ibn Sa'd: “The people of your city wrote to me and invited me. If they are displeased by my coming, I will return.”
«کتب إلى أهل مصرکم هذا أن أقدم، فأما إذ کرهونی فأنا أنصرف عنهم»!؛ (“The people of your city wrote to me and invited me. If they are displeased by my coming, I will return!”).
Yazid’s aim was to secure Imam Husayn’s pledge of allegiance, and that pledge would have meant the destruction of Islam!
The Imam was therefore faced with a choice between pledging allegiance and going to war—and war had been forced upon him!
فانصرف إلى عمر بن سعد فأخبره الخبر ، فقال له عمر بن سعد : إنی لأرجو أن یعافینی الله من حربه و قتاله ، و کتب إلى ابن زیاد بذلک ، وأجاب ابن زیاد : أعرض على الحسین أن یبایع لیزید بن معاویه هو وجمیع أصحابه ، فإذا فعل ذلک رأینا رأینا . فلما انتهى کتابه إلى عمر بن سعد قال : ما أحسب ابن زیاد یرید العافیه . فارسل عمر بن سعد بکتاب ابن زیاد إلى الحسین ، فقال الحسین علیه السلام للرسول : لا أجیب ابن زیاد بذلک أبدا ، فهل هو إلا الموت ، فمرحبا به .
Al-Mustafa (PBUH) Center, *The Words of Imam Husayn*, p. 381
When Umar ibn Sa'd’s messenger returned and informed him of what had happened, Ibn Sa'd said: “I hope God will spare me from fighting Husayn (peace be upon him).” He then conveyed the Imam’s request to Ubayd Allah ibn Ziyad. In reply, Ubayd Allah wrote to Master Ali Saei in response to question number: “Ask Husayn ibn Ali (peace be upon him) to pledge allegiance to Yazid ibn Mu'awiya, along with all his companions. If he does so, we will state our decision...!”
When Ibn Sa'd received Ibn Ziyad’s letter, he said: “I do not think Ubayd Allah ibn Ziyad wants peace or reconciliation.”
Umar ibn Sa'd sent the text of Ubayd Allah ibn Ziyad’s letter to Imam Husayn (peace be upon him).
The Imam (peace be upon him) said: «لا أجیب ابن زیاد بذلک ابدا، فهل هو إلا الموت، فمرحبا به»؛ (“I will never answer Ibn Ziyad’s letter in that way. What can come of it but death? Welcome, then, to such a death!”).
Divine permission to fight in the circumstances of war during a sacred month!
البقره : 194 الشهر الحرام بالشهر الحرام و الحرمات قصاص فمن اعتدى علیکم فاعتدوا علیه بمثل ما اعتدى علیکم و اتقوا الله و اعلموا أن الله مع المتقین
The sacred month is to be met with a sacred month! (If the enemy violates its sanctity and fights you during it, you too have the right to respond in kind.) All that is sacred is subject to retaliation. So whoever transgresses against you, respond in kind to the extent of the transgression against you. Be mindful of God, and do not exceed the bounds. Know that God is with the God-fearing.
Imam Husayn (peace be upon him) did not initiate the war; it was forced upon him!
An important point:
The true reality of the sacred months—their inner meaning and esoteric interpretation—is the Infallible Imams themselves. Any conflict with them is forbidden!
... و نحن الشهر الحرام و نحن البلد الحرام و نحن کعبه الله و نحن قبله الله ...
Al-Burhan fi Tafsir al-Qur'an, vol. 1, p. 52
Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq (peace be upon him): “... We are the sacred month, we are the sacred land, we are the Ka'ba of God, and we are the direction of prayer toward God...”