Why, during the prostration in Ziyarat Ashura, do we praise and thank God for the great tragedy of the martyrdom of the Master of Martyrs?
Why Do We Praise God for the Tragedy of the Master of Martyrs during the Prostration in Ziyarat Ashura?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Praising and thanking God in every circumstance, in times of joy and sorrow alike, is part of the etiquette of servitude. The tragedy of Imam Hussein (AS) is one of those calamities whose immense blessings have profoundly affected the whole of existence, calling for gratitude and praise on several levels: for the tragedy itself, and for its effects and blessings in strengthening faith, certainty, and devotion to God.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterPraise and thanks must be offered to God in every circumstance—whether in joy or sorrow, whether in health and well-being or pain and illness, whether in youth or old age, and likewise in times of poverty or wealth, hardship and affliction or ease. The etiquette of servitude requires that we praise God in every state.
No state or condition ever comes to pass unless the One God has decreed and ordained it. Health, well-being, ease and happiness are the result of the seal of approval of the Lord who originates, wills, measures, judges and executes. Likewise, hardships and afflictions will not come into being until He issues permission for their occurrence. So Allah, our God, is present in both ease and hardship, and our praise is a kiss upon the seal of the All-Knowing, All-Holy Lord.
The supreme affliction of the Master of Martyrs, peace be upon him, is among those afflictions that have borne immense blessed effects upon the universe—such that we owe a multi-layered and parallel gratitude and praise for this affliction: one for the affliction itself, and another for its effects and blessings upon religion, certainty, spiritual fruitfulness and servitude to God.
Imam Husayn, peace be upon him, on the night of Ashura:
أحمده على السراء و الضراء
Al-Husayn gathered his companions near the close of the evening. Ali ibn al-Husayn Zayn al-Abidin, peace be upon him, said: I drew near to hear what he would say to them, being ill at that time, and I heard my father say to his companions: "I extol Allah with the finest praise and I thank Him in prosperity and adversity. O Allah, I praise You for having honoured us with prophethood, taught us the Quran, granted us understanding in religion, and given us ears, eyes and hearts—so make us among the thankful. To proceed..."
الإرشاد فی معرفه حجج الله على العباد، ج2، ص: 91
He said: "O Commander of the Faithful, if it were one house, or two, or three, we could manage it—but from this tribe there will be one hundred and eighty slain, and there is no house but that weeping will be in it. As for us men, we do not weep, but we rejoice for them. Shall we not rejoice for them in martyrdom?" So Ali said: "May Allah have mercy on your slain and your dead."
وقعه صفین، النص، ص: 531
"And your two grandsons, Hasan and Husayn—I made Hasan the mine of My knowledge after the term of his father, and I made Husayn the treasurer of My revelation, and I honoured him with martyrdom and sealed his end with felicity. He is the most excellent of those who have been martyred and the highest of the martyrs in rank. I placed My perfect word with him and My conclusive proof in his keeping. Through his progeny I reward and I punish. The first of them is Ali, the Master of the Worshippers and the ornament of My devoted friends of old..."
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج1، ص: 527
"Praise be to Allah who honoured us with aiding you and ennobled us with being slain alongside you. Are you not content that we should be with you in your station, O son of the Messenger of Allah?"
الهدایه الکبرى، ص: 204
(1) اللهم لک الحمد على ما لم أزل أتصرف فیه من سلامه بدنی، و لک الحمد على ما أحدثت بی من عله فی جسدی (2) فما أدری، یا إلهی، أی الحالین أحق بالشکر لک، و أی الوقتین أولى بالحمد لک (3) أ وقت الصحه التی هنأتنی فیها طیبات رزقک، و نشطتنی بها لابتغاء مرضاتک و فضلک، و قویتنی معها على ما وفقتنی له من طاعتک (4) أم وقت العله التی محصتنی بها، و النعم التی أتحفتنی بها، تخفیفا لما ثقل به علی ظهری من الخطیئات، و تطهیرا لما انغمست فیه من السیئات، و تنبیها لتناول التوبه، و تذکیرا لمحو الحوبه بقدیم النعمه
A portion of the 15th supplication of Sahifa Sajjadiyya:
O God, praise be to You for the health of body through which I continue to move about, and praise be to You for this illness You have brought upon my body. I do not know, O my God, which of the two states is more deserving of my gratitude to You, and which of the two times is more worthy of my praise of You—whether the time of health, in which You granted me the pure delights of Your provision, stirred me to seek Your pleasure and bounty, and strengthened me for the obedience to which You guided me; or this time of illness, through which You have purified me, and the afflictions You have bestowed upon me as a gift—lightening the burden of sins that weighed upon my back, cleansing me of the wrongdoings in which I was immersed, awakening me to embrace repentance, and reminding me of the erasure of transgression through Your ancient favour.
الصحیفه السجادیه / ترجمه آیتى، ص: 97
"He who deserves that every creature thank and praise Him—I praise Him in prosperity and adversity, in hardship and ease."
Lady Zaynab, peace be upon her, addressing Ibn Ziyad, may God curse him:
ما رأیت إلا جمیلا
Imam Sajjad, peace be upon him, addressing Ibn Ziyad, may God curse him: "Do you threaten me with death, O Ibn Ziyad? Do you not know that death is our custom and martyrdom our honour?"
اللهوف على قتلى الطفوف / ترجمه فهرى، النص، ص: 163