Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 1080 20 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Why Have We Not Built a True Islamic Civilization?

Primary reference: See the answer text 38 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-1080

Greetings, and may your acts of worship be accepted. I would be grateful if my dear teacher could explain why, after fourteen hundred years of Islam, we have still been unable to build a truly Islamic society and civilization.

For example, there may be countries in the world with no religion that have nevertheless used human reason to build societies that, while far from perfect, are better than ours. Some people of learning might say, “No, those societies have countless problems that they themselves fail to see,” and so on. Of course, since our claim to offer humanity salvation is greater, perhaps this comparison is unfair. But the comparison exists, and cannot simply be denied.

So the question arises: is the problem with us, or with our religion? In these fourteen hundred years—a fairly long time, after all—why have we not found, say, a million or even a hundred thousand people who truly practise Islam and thereby advance society morally, spiritually and materially?

It is like my inventing a mobile phone that, for a thousand years, large numbers of people cannot figure out how to use, while I continue to blame them for their inability and insist that there is nothing wrong with the phone or its software.

I would be grateful to hear my dear teacher’s thoughts on this. With thanks. Of course, this question does not necessarily reflect my personal views. Ya Ali.

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

The failure to establish a true Islamic civilization after 1,400 years is not due to any weakness in the faith, but to straying from it and failing to put its pure teachings into practice. Throughout history, the storehouses of knowledge have been kept under lock and key by hypocrites; in recent centuries, the Islamic world has been subject to conspiracies and led by the unqualified. Iran’s scientific progress in recent years has been remarkable, but international pressure has sought to obstruct it. Islam is a religion of knowledge, and the Islamic world’s scientific stagnation has stemmed from its distance from the faith.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

Knowledge surges and wells up from the soul of religion. Not everyone who looks like a Muslim is a Muslim. To examine the influence of religion on scientific progress and the role of the Islamic world in the development of science and technology, we must give full attention to several matters! To discover the role of the Islamic world in science and technology, we must examine the entire last fourteen hundred years, not just a segment of it; surely the world is not summed up in the last two hundred years! If we look beyond the last hundred or two hundred years, we will find that the Islamic world was at the forefront of science and technology! After the coup of Saqifa, Islam was unable to reveal its truth and reality fully and completely; the treasures of knowledge were imprisoned and locked away by the hypocrites, and the opportunity for them to emerge rarely arose! If we look carefully, the management of the principal and foundational pillars of science across the entire globe is administered by Muslims—that is, the principal management of science in the world is in the hands of Muslim minds, minds that have been abducted and expropriated. Let us consider the mafia of science, which has not allowed Muslims to emerge and become visible—that is, they benefit from their minds and their knowledge without a name being mentioned, or they register it under their own names and take the prize themselves, such as the Nobel Prize and the like! A kind of silent theft of science and technology from the soul of Islam and Muslims is taking place! Over roughly the past two hundred years, a kind of conspiracy has been carried out against the Islamic world, and through various tricks the leadership of the Islamic world in Muslim lands has fallen into the hands of the unworthy, which has become a cause of scientific suffocation in these lands. In the past thirty-odd years, scientific progress in Iran, due to the particular conditions it has, has dazzled eyes around the world, and there is no room for any denial. Of course, we must pay attention to the volume of pressures exerted on our country to make it abandon this scientific uprising and movement! The fundamental point is that the scientific stagnation in the Islamic world has been due to deviation from religion, not due to religious adherence! Which country in the Islamic world, really, is fully obedient to the pure rulings of Islam?! The religion of Islam means the religion of knowledge!

Peace be upon you, my dear professor. The discussion is about this question: why have none of the Islamic countries been, and are not, obedient to the pure rulings of Islam? Is it the compulsion of the age? Or is it simply not possible to reach the desired destination by this route? Also, the claim that Islam's progress slowed two hundred years ago cannot be accepted, because even at the peak of Islam's advancement, in the fourth and fifth centuries AH, we did not have such a great civilization—for example, we were not the initiators of the Industrial Revolution. Perhaps it is better to say that Europe was behind, rather than that we were in the lead. Moreover, the use of the sciences of ancient Greece, which Muslims gained access to through the translation movement, should not be overlooked. Likewise, some of the civic matters that the West has brought forth and that have to some extent proven themselves—such as democracy or the separation of powers—certainly cannot be sought in the Prophetic tradition or the conduct of the Imams. Also, regarding your statement that a kind of theft of scientists has occurred on the part of the West, this comes to mind: well, your point is correct, but when did the knowledge of these individuals find the opportunity to emerge? It was where conditions were suitable, and at present the West has created those conditions better than we have, and one cannot call that theft; perhaps "win-win transaction" is a more accurate term. And regarding the leadership of Muslim societies, one could say: it suffices for you to take a look at the course of the seminaries over these four or five hundred years—did the intellectual sciences have the opportunity to assert themselves? Were geography and other subjects taught? At the time when in Europe scientists were busy drawing maps of the earth, here we were busy with the doubts concerning prayer. In your view, is this the fault of the West or of us? It seems it is better to put ourselves on trial than to exonerate ourselves with conspiracy theory and lay everything at the feet of the West and their ruthless plots. Thank you.

#Answer1080 Part Two

The Well-spring of Knowledge Flows from the Heart of Religion

If we pay attention to just the first sermon of Nahj al-Balagha, we will grasp the heights of Islamic scholarship. The West’s acknowledgment of the role of Islamic civilization in global progress is its own admission. The translation movement was a political tool intended to overshadow the unique role and pre-eminence of the Infallible Imams علیهم السلام. Much of the Muslims’ intellectual wealth has been plundered by the West; many theories and principles developed by Muslims have been appropriated by the West; and much of the work, influence and inventiveness of Muslims has been marginalized or stolen. Intellectual theft has been rampant in this age and over the past two hundred years!

Search the internet, and you will discover the role of the Islamic world in global progress!

Knowing what to do when one has doubts during prayer has nothing to do with a lack of scientific progress. Every believer needs to know their duties when in doubt, and learning them takes little time: they can be learned in just a few minutes. No Muslim has devoted all their attention to such doubts and similar matters. This kind of criticism is more a taunt than anything else. Besides, every scholar speaks within their own field: a religious scholar about religion, a psychologist about human behaviour. No one expects a psychologist to invent an aeroplane! And to ignore the contributions of Islamic scholars to the advancement of science and technology worldwide is profoundly unfair.

Democracy in the West is largely symbolic. Freedom in the Western world seems to mean little beyond freedom for immorality and a few other things. Expressing an opinion about the Holocaust or questioning their fundamental premises crosses a red line. They may allow people to criticise or insult their president and other leaders, but their foundational principles remain fiercely guarded and off limits!

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022