Why must Lady Fatima, peace be upon her, be lost to history—not only in terms of where she was buried, which can be explained and is not the question I am asking, but also in terms of when she died? The Shia have managed to record the birth and death dates of all the Infallibles (AS), so why could they not record the date of Lady Fatima’s birth and, especially, her martyrdom? What makes this all the more striking is that it happened after the great tragedy of the Prophet’s (PBUH) martyrdom. Yet the dates remain uncertain... Why?
Why Is the Date of Lady Fatima’s (SA) Martyrdom Unknown?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The fact that the exact date of Lady Fatima’s (SA) martyrdom and the place where she was buried have remained unknown is one of the mysteries of creation. It has led people to remember her in a special way and has helped keep the teachings of the Ahl al-Bayt (AS) alive. Two different accounts place her martyrdom 75 and 95 days after the Prophet’s (PBUH) passing, giving rise to the first and second Fatimiyya commemorations.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterIf we reflect carefully on the days commemorating the martyrdom of Lady Zahra سلام الله علیها, we see that Ali and Fatima سلام الله علیهما were solitary and wronged figures of their time. The Muslim community treated the Ahl al-Bayt علیهم السلام with an injustice without parallel. It disobeyed God and His Messenger and showed no care or regard for the Ahl al-Bayt علیهم السلام—let alone any interest in their history and what befell them!
The exact date of her martyrdom has remained unknown, just like her burial place. This concealment is among the mysteries of creation. It has led Lady Zahra سلام الله علیها to be remembered in a distinctive way and has strengthened the Shia cause in its efforts to promote the Ahl al-Bayt علیهم السلام.
In truth, however, there is no day that is not Fatima’s day! Every day is the day of Muhammad, Ali, Fatima, Hasan and Husayn علیهم السلام. The days of Fatimiyya are an added blessing for the Shia, making it possible for Lady Zahra سلام الله علیها to be remembered in a special and particular way.
### A discussion of the days of Fatimiyya
There are two different accounts of the date of the martyrdom of Hazrat Fatima سلام الله علیها. One places it seventy-five days after the passing of Hazrat Muhammad صلی الله علیه و آله و سلم, while the other gives ninety-five days. Since Hazrat Muhammad صلی الله علیه و آله و سلم passed away on the twenty-eighth of Safar, the account of seventy-five days places “the first Fatimiyya” between the thirteenth and fifteenth of Jumada al-Awwal. According to the account of ninety-five days, Fatima’s سلام الله علیها martyrdom fell between the third and fifth of Jumada al-Thani, and these days are called “the second Fatimiyya.”
The reason three days in each month are given as possible dates for her martyrdom may be that the lunar months between the Prophet’s (PBUH) passing and the martyrdom of Hazrat Fatima Zahra (SA) may have had twenty-nine days. If the preceding months were complete, however, the date would be the thirteenth of Jumada al-Awwal or the third of Jumada al-Thani. According to the calendar, no more than three lunar months of twenty-nine days, or four lunar months of thirty days, can occur consecutively.
According to the account given by Shaykh al-Kulayni—may God have mercy on him—in *Usul al-Kafi*, which dates the passing of Hazrat Muhammad صلی الله علیه و آله و سلم to the twelfth of Rabi al-Awwal, there is also a third Fatimiyya.
In popular usage, the ten days from the tenth to the twentieth of Jumada al-Awwal are called “the first ten days of Fatimiyya,” since, according to the seventy-five-day account, Fatima’s سلام الله علیها martyrdom falls within them. The first ten days of Jumada al-Thani, from the first to the tenth of the month, are called “the second ten days of Fatimiyya,” since, according to the ninety-five-day account, her martyrdom falls within that period.
Among Iraqi Shia, rather than two periods, three are observed. “The first ten days of Fatimiyya” begin forty days after the passing of Hazrat Muhammad صلی الله علیه و آله و سلم, on the eighth of Rabi al-Thani.
### The reason for the difference in dates
At first, Arabic writing had no signs at all—neither dots nor vowel marks. As a result, most letters shared the same shapes and were indistinguishable from one another. For this reason, “seventy” (in Arabic: سبعون) and “ninety” (in Arabic: تسعون) were written alike in Arabic, making them difficult for historians in later periods to tell apart.