Greetings, Professor. Could you please comment on the view held by some scholars that, after the Imam’s death, he cannot hear what his visitors say, and that angels relay their words to him? I asked them: if we do not regard the Imam as infallible, but consider him simply a martyr, then, in light of the verse «و لا تحسبن الذین قتلو فی سبیل الله.....», the Imam is alive—and a living person can hear what others say. Unless, of course, being alive here has a different meaning. Their reply was that if worldly life and life in the barzakh were no different, one Imam would not have succeeded another. But this answer, too, requires us to consider what those differences are. I would be grateful if you could critique their response. Thank you.
A Critique of Scholars’ Views on Whether the Imam Hears Visitors after Death
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
After death, the Imam’s soul is able to hear what visitors say; there is no need for angels to act as intermediaries. Just as the martyrs are alive and aware of the believers’ condition, as the verse «و لا تحسبن الذین قتلوا فی سبیل الله أمواتا بل أحیاء عند ربهم یرزقون» states, so too is the Imam. He receives a visitor’s greeting directly.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThere is no reason to think that angels can receive a pilgrim’s salutation while the Imam’s spirit is unable to receive it!
The salutation at the end of the prayer, after the tashahhud, is a direct salutation. When a person reaches the concluding salutation after the tashahhud, they offer it directly; they are not addressing the angels. There is no transmitted evidence for such mediation. Moreover, if the angels were intermediaries in conveying the salutation, the wording would surely be different—for example: يا ملائكة الله بلغوا سلامي ...
Yet our salutations are offered in this way:
السلام علیک أیها النبی و رحمه الله و برکاته
السلام علینا و على عباد الله الصالحین السلام علیکم و رحمه الله و برکاته
A careful examination of the verse about the martyrs reveals truths about their direct connection with the people of this world.
Āl ʿImrān 3:169: و لا تحسبن الذین قتلوا فی سبیل الله أمواتا بل أحیاء عند ربهم یرزقون
Āl ʿImrān 3:170: فرحین بما آتاهم الله من فضله و یستبشرون بالذین لم یلحقوا بهم من خلفهم ألا خوف علیهم و لا هم یحزنون
“Never think of those who have been killed in God’s way as dead. Rather, they are alive, sustained in the presence of their Lord.” (169)
“They rejoice in the bounty God has bestowed upon them, and they give glad tidings to those who have not yet joined them, who remain behind: they will have no fear, nor will they grieve.” (170)
The next verse about the martyrs speaks of their glad tidings to their brothers in faith who are still living on earth!
عن برید العجلی قال: سألت أبا جعفر ع- عن قول الله عز و جل- و یستبشرون
بالذین لم یلحقوا بهم من خلفهم
ألا خوف علیهم و لا هم یحزنون «1» قال هم و الله شیعتنا حین صارت أرواحهم فی الجنه و استقبلوا الکرامه من الله عز و جل علموا و استیقنوا أنهم کانوا على الحق و على دین الله عز و جل و استبشروا بمن لم یلحق بهم من إخوانهم من خلفهم من المؤمنین ألا خوف علیهم و لا هم یحزنون.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه), vol. 8, p. 156
Burayd al-ʿIjlī relates: I asked Imam al-Bāqir, peace be upon him, about the verse, “...and they give glad tidings to those who have not yet joined them, who remain behind: they will have no fear, nor will they grieve.” His Eminence, peace be upon him, replied: “By God, they are our Shia. When their spirits enter Paradise and they are received with honor by God, Mighty and Exalted, they will know and be certain that they were upon the truth and the religion of God, Mighty and Exalted. And they will give glad tidings to their brothers among the believers who have not yet joined them, who remain behind: they will have no fear, nor will they grieve.”
Paradise of al-Kafi / Translation of Rawdat al-Kafi, p. 200.