At a celebration of the birth of Imam Ali (AS), Mr. Seyyed Mousavi said that if it were not for the Imams (AS), no one on earth would be healed (his example was that God is an intercessor in nine cases).
Should we ask the Imams (AS) for healing instead of praying to God?
If the Imams did not exist, could God not heal? (نعوذ و نستعیذ بالله)
If God is the absolute power over all existence and nonexistence, why should He make every act of mercy, healing, and the like dependent on the existence of the Imams (AS)? Is this (نعوذ و نستعیذ بالله) a kind of division of labor?
A critique of the statement, “If it were not for the Imams, no one would be healed?”
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
God Almighty has no need of any intermediary to heal; medicine has an effect only by His permission. The Imams (AS) intercede for divine healing. They are themselves among God’s Most Beautiful Names and are channels of His mercy and healing, receiving permission to heal from God.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterI do not recall Mr. Mousavi’s remarks or the way he put his point, but what we have learned from the teachings of Mishkat is this:
The Almighty God has no need of any intermediary to heal the sick. If He has made medicine a means of healing, it is because of a wisdom established by the All-Wise Himself.
Unless the Creator grants medicine permission to heal, it will have no effect. And unless the Lord commands the illness to depart, the pain and sickness will not go away.
The Infallible Imams علیهم السلام intercede for divine healing, and permission to intercede and to heal is granted by none other than the One and Only God!
They are the Most Beautiful Names of God, one of which is the sacred name of the Healer.
If Almighty God establishes a means through which His healing and mercy may flow, no one has grounds to call it into question—for it is the will of the All-Powerful, and the Imams themselves are that divine mercy, blessing, and healing!
الأنبیاء : 23 لا یسئل عما یفعل و هم یسئلون
No one can find fault with what He does, while their actions may be questioned and challenged!
و عتره خیره رب العالمین و رحمه الله و برکاته
But your statement that “God is the absolute power of nothingness” is meaningless!