Are actions inherently good or bad, regardless of God’s commands and prohibitions?
Are Actions Inherently Good or Bad?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The goodness and badness of actions are understood in terms of the paths of obedience and disobedience. Reason, when it obeys God, is beautiful and beloved; ignorance, when it rebels, is ugly. The goodness of created things reflects divine goodness, while ugliness points to deviant conduct. Justice becomes more beautiful when understood as a sign of the Lord’s goodness.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterAccording to the hadith of Intellect and Ignorance, goodness and evil mean nothing other than following the path of obedience or disobedience!
Everything is beautiful through intellect, because it heeds God’s command:
لما خلق الله العقل استنطقه ثم قال له أقبل فأقبل ثم قال له أدبر فأدبر
Ignorance disobeyed God’s command and became ugly. Had it followed the path of obedience, it would have been beloved, just like intellect!
ثم خلق الجهل من البحر الأجاج ظلمانیا فقال له أدبر فأدبر ثم قال له أقبل فلم یقبل
القصص : 42 و أتبعناهم فی هذه الدنیا لعنه و یوم القیامه هم من المقبوحین
“And in this world We made a curse follow them, and on the Day of Resurrection they will be among the disfigured.”
Since this subject has been repeated, I will refrain from further explanation!
See #Answer87.
A follow-up to #Question970: Thank you, استاد. Am I wrong in saying this? Intellect and innate nature, which are the criteria for judging the goodness or evil of actions, were determined by God, after all. And if God had wanted, He could have determined them differently. In reality, we have a number of created beings, some of whom obey the Lord and others who disobey Him; and, according to the formula of intellect and innate nature, we consider those who obey God to be good. My question is: Are all actions created? For example, is justice also created?! So that, if it is in obedience, it is good—and otherwise, evil?
Answer 970:
+ Follow-up
The goodness of created beings reflects the sign of divine goodness, whereas ugliness is a mark of their deviation!
What we call ugliness and evil is, in fact, an understanding derived from the deviant conduct of created beings. Their disobedient conduct has a reflection that we interpret as ugliness and evil. If that same act, in the same form and with the same characteristics, were carried out along the path of obedience, it would be understood as beautiful!
As a formula: travelling the path with intellect as one’s mount charts the path of goodness, while travelling with ignorance as one’s mount charts the path of ugliness!
It is more fitting to understand justice as a sign of the Lord’s goodness.