Peace be upon you, teacher. Could you please explain the Ashʿari view of justice? Could it be right?
They say: Justice is not an independently existing reality that can be defined in advance and made a measure or standard for the Lord’s actions. To set a measure or standard for God’s actions would, in effect, be to prescribe what He must do and to limit and circumscribe the will and volition of the Exalted Real. How could a law be laid down for the actions of the Exalted Real and then made to govern Him and His actions? To say that the Essence of the Real is just does not mean that He follows pre-existing rules called justice. It means that He is the source of justice: whatever He does is just, not that He does whatever is just.